diff --git a/Manuscript/G2-srDFT.bib b/Manuscript/G2-srDFT.bib index 85134da..b541937 100644 --- a/Manuscript/G2-srDFT.bib +++ b/Manuscript/G2-srDFT.bib @@ -7832,6 +7832,7 @@ @article{MusReiAngTou-JCP-15, Author = {B. Mussard and P. Reinhardt and J. G. \'Angy\'an and J. Toulouse}, + title = {Spin-unrestricted random-phase approximation with range separation: Benchmark on atomization energies and reaction barrier heights}, Journal = {J. Chem. Phys.}, Note = {Erratum: J. Chem. Phys. {\bf 142}, 219901 (2015)}, Pages = {154123}, diff --git a/Manuscript/G2-srDFT.tex b/Manuscript/G2-srDFT.tex index 29f2aec..8ae8c32 100644 --- a/Manuscript/G2-srDFT.tex +++ b/Manuscript/G2-srDFT.tex @@ -73,7 +73,7 @@ \newcommand{\Ec}{E_\text{c}} \newcommand{\E}[2]{E_{#1}^{#2}} \newcommand{\bE}[2]{\Bar{E}_{#1}^{#2}} -\newcommand{\bEc}[1]{\Bar{E}_\text{c}^{#1}} +\newcommand{\bEc}[1]{\Bar{E}_\text{c,md}^{#1}} \newcommand{\e}[2]{\varepsilon_{#1}^{#2}} \newcommand{\be}[2]{\Bar{\varepsilon}_{#1}^{#2}} \newcommand{\bec}[1]{\Bar{e}^{#1}} @@ -118,7 +118,7 @@ \begin{document} -\title{A Density-Based Basis Set Correction For Wave Function Theory} +\title{A Density-Based Basis-Set Correction For Wave-Function Theory} \author{Pierre-Fran\c{c}ois Loos} \email{loos@irsamc.ups-tlse.fr} @@ -141,7 +141,7 @@ \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{TOC} \end{wrapfigure} We report a universal density-based basis set incompleteness correction that can be applied to any wave function method. -The present correction, which appropriately vanishes in the complete basis set (CBS) limit, relies on short-range correlation density functionals (with multi-determinant reference) from range-separated density-functional theory (RS-DFT) to estimate the basis set incompleteness error. +The present correction, which appropriately vanishes in the complete-basis-set (CBS) limit, relies on short-range correlation density functionals (with multi-determinant reference) from range-separated density-functional theory (RS-DFT) to estimate the basis set incompleteness error. Contrary to conventional RS-DFT schemes which require an \textit{ad hoc} range-separation \textit{parameter} $\mu$, the key ingredient here is a range-separation \textit{function} $\mu(\bf{r})$ which automatically adapts to the spatial non-homogeneity of the basis set incompleteness error. As illustrative examples, we show how this density-based correction allows us to obtain CCSD(T) atomization and correlation energies near the CBS limit for the G2 set of molecules with compact Gaussian basis sets. \end{abstract} @@ -154,7 +154,7 @@ As illustrative examples, we show how this density-based correction allows us to Contemporary quantum chemistry has developed in two directions --- wave function theory (WFT) \cite{Pop-RMP-99} and density-functional theory (DFT). \cite{Koh-RMP-99} Although both spring from the same Schr\"odinger equation, each of these philosophies has its own \textit{pros} and \textit{cons}. -WFT is attractive as it exists a well-defined path for systematic improvement as well as powerful tools, such as perturbation theory, to guide the development of new attractive WFT \textit{ans\"atze}. +WFT is attractive as it exists a well-defined path for systematic improvement as well as powerful tools, such as perturbation theory, to guide the development of new WFT \textit{ans\"atze}. The coupled cluster (CC) family of methods is a typical example of the WFT philosophy and is well regarded as the gold standard of quantum chemistry for weakly correlated systems. By increasing the excitation degree of the CC expansion, one can systematically converge, for a given basis set, to the exact, full configuration interaction (FCI) limit, although the computational cost associated with such improvement is usually high. One of the most fundamental drawbacks of conventional WFT methods is the slow convergence of energies and properties with respect to the size of the one-electron basis set. @@ -165,23 +165,23 @@ For example, at the CCSD(T) level, one can obtain quintuple-$\zeta$ quality corr To reduce further the computational cost and/or ease the transferability of the F12 correction, approximated and/or universal schemes have recently emerged. \cite{TorVal-JCP-09, KonVal-JCP-10, KonVal-JCP-11, BooCleAlaTew-JCP-2012, IrmHumGru-arXiv-2019, IrmGru-arXiv-2019} Present-day DFT calculations are almost exclusively done within the so-called Kohn-Sham (KS) formalism, which corresponds to an exact dressed one-electron theory. \cite{KohSha-PR-65} -DFT's attractiveness originates from its very favorable cost/efficiency ratio as it can provide accurate energies and properties at a relatively low computational cost. +DFT's attractiveness originates from its very favorable cost/accuracy ratio as it often provides reasonably accurate energies and properties at a relatively low computational cost. Thanks to this, KS-DFT \cite{HohKoh-PR-64, KohSha-PR-65} has become the workhorse of electronic structure calculations for atoms, molecules and solids. \cite{ParYan-BOOK-89} -Although there is no clear way on how to systematically improve density-functional approximations, \cite{Bec-JCP-14} climbing the Jacob's ladder of DFT is potentially the most satisfactory way forward. \cite{PerSch-AIPCP-01, PerRuzTaoStaScuCso-JCP-05} +Although there is no clear way on how to systematically improve density-functional approximations, \cite{Bec-JCP-14} climbing Perdew's ladder of DFT is potentially the most satisfactory way forward. \cite{PerSch-AIPCP-01, PerRuzTaoStaScuCso-JCP-05} In the context of the present work, one of the interesting feature of density-based methods is their much faster convergence with respect to the size of the basis set. \cite{FraMusLupTou-JCP-15} Progress toward unifying WFT and DFT are on-going. -In particular, range-separated DFT (RS-DFT) (see Ref.~\onlinecite{TouColSav-PRA-04} and references therein) rigorously combines these two approaches via a decomposition of the electron-electron (e-e) interaction into a smooth long-range part and a (complementary) short-range part treated with WFT and DFT, respectively. +In particular, range-separated DFT (RS-DFT) (see Ref.~\onlinecite{TouColSav-PRA-04} and references therein) rigorously combines these two approaches via a decomposition of the electron-electron (e-e) interaction into a non-divergent long-range part and a (complementary) short-range part treated with WFT and DFT, respectively. As the WFT method is relieved from describing the short-range part of the correlation hole around the e-e coalescence points, the convergence with respect to the one-electron basis set is greatly improved. \cite{FraMusLupTou-JCP-15} -Therefore, a number of approximate RS-DFT schemes have been developed within single-reference \cite{AngGerSavTou-PRA-05, GolWerSto-PCCP-05, TouGerJanSavAng-PRL-09,JanHenScu-JCP-09} or multi-reference \cite{LeiStoWerSav-CPL-97, FroTouJen-JCP-07, FroCimJen-PRA-10, HedKneKieJenRei-JCP-15, FerGinTou-JCP-18} WFT approaches. +Therefore, a number of approximate RS-DFT schemes have been developed within single-reference \cite{AngGerSavTou-PRA-05, GolWerSto-PCCP-05, TouGerJanSavAng-PRL-09,JanHenScu-JCP-09, TouZhuSavJanAng-JCP-11, MusReiAngTou-JCP-15} or multi-reference \cite{LeiStoWerSav-CPL-97, FroTouJen-JCP-07, FroCimJen-PRA-10, HedKneKieJenRei-JCP-15, HedTouJen-JCP-18, FerGinTou-JCP-18} WFT approaches. -Very recently, a major step forward has been taken by some of the present authors thanks to the development of a density-based basis set correction for WFT methods. \cite{GinPraFerAssSavTou-JCP-18} +Very recently, a major step forward has been taken by some of the present authors thanks to the development of a density-based basis-set correction for WFT methods. \cite{GinPraFerAssSavTou-JCP-18} The present work proposes an extension of this new methodological development alongside the first numerical tests on molecular systems. %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% %\section{Theory} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% -The present basis set correction relies on the RS-DFT formalism to capture the missing part of the short-range correlation effects, a consequence of the incompleteness of the one-electron basis set. +The present basis-set correction relies on the RS-DFT formalism to capture the missing part of the short-range correlation effects, a consequence of the incompleteness of the one-electron basis set. Here, we only provide the main working equations. We refer the interested reader to Ref.~\onlinecite{GinPraFerAssSavTou-JCP-18} for a more formal derivation. @@ -201,8 +201,8 @@ where - \min_{\wf{}{\Bas} \to \n{}{}} \mel*{\wf{}{\Bas}}{\hT + \hWee{}}{\wf{}{\Bas}} \end{equation} is the basis-dependent complementary density functional, $\hT$ is the kinetic operator and $\hWee{} = \sum_{i