From 566de9c3ca2ac73b5913e71ba81b91576a43d5ce Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Pierre-Francois Loos Date: Fri, 3 Jun 2022 10:10:31 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] CASSCF fig --- Data/CASPT3.nb | 912 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++- Manuscript/CASPT3.tex | 12 +- Manuscript/fig2a.pdf | Bin 0 -> 20847 bytes Manuscript/{fig2.pdf => fig2b.pdf} | Bin Response_Letter/Response_Letter.tex | 21 +- 5 files changed, 914 insertions(+), 31 deletions(-) create mode 100644 Manuscript/fig2a.pdf rename Manuscript/{fig2.pdf => fig2b.pdf} (100%) diff --git a/Data/CASPT3.nb b/Data/CASPT3.nb index 237a76c..07224b5 100644 --- a/Data/CASPT3.nb +++ b/Data/CASPT3.nb @@ -10,10 +10,10 @@ NotebookFileLineBreakTest NotebookFileLineBreakTest NotebookDataPosition[ 158, 7] -NotebookDataLength[ 1289234, 25065] -NotebookOptionsPosition[ 1285992, 24999] -NotebookOutlinePosition[ 1286390, 25015] -CellTagsIndexPosition[ 1286347, 25012] +NotebookDataLength[ 1328597, 25927] +NotebookOptionsPosition[ 1325125, 25857] +NotebookOutlinePosition[ 1325522, 25873] +CellTagsIndexPosition[ 1325479, 25870] WindowFrame->Normal*) (* Beginning of Notebook Content *) @@ -79,6 +79,864 @@ Cell[BoxData[ Cell[CellGroupData[{ +Cell[BoxData[{ + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"WFT", "=", + RowBox[{"{", + RowBox[{"\"\\"", ","}], "}"}]}], ";"}], "\[IndentingNewLine]", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"MAE", "=", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"Import", "[", "\"\\"", "]"}], + "\[LeftDoubleBracket]", + RowBox[{"Sheet", ",", + RowBox[{"3", ";;", "286"}], ",", + RowBox[{"41", "+", + RowBox[{"{", "18", "}"}]}]}], "\[RightDoubleBracket]"}]}], + ";"}], "\[IndentingNewLine]", + RowBox[{"graph", "=", "\[IndentingNewLine]", + RowBox[{"Show", "[", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"{", "\[IndentingNewLine]", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"Histogram", "[", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"MAE", "\[LeftDoubleBracket]", + RowBox[{";;", ",", "1"}], "\[RightDoubleBracket]"}], ",", "20", ",", + "\"\\"", ",", + RowBox[{"PlotTheme", "\[Rule]", "\"\\""}], ",", + RowBox[{"BaseStyle", "\[Rule]", "14"}], ",", + RowBox[{"PlotRange", "\[Rule]", + RowBox[{"{", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"{", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"-", "2.2"}], ",", + RowBox[{"+", "2.2"}]}], "}"}], ",", "Automatic"}], "}"}]}], ",", + + RowBox[{"FrameLabel", "\[Rule]", + RowBox[{"{", + RowBox[{"\"\\"", ",", "None"}], "}"}]}], ",", + RowBox[{"ChartStyle", "\[Rule]", + RowBox[{"{", + RowBox[{"Directive", "[", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"Opacity", "[", "0.5", "]"}], ",", "Black"}], "]"}], + "}"}]}], ",", + RowBox[{"FrameTicks", "\[Rule]", + RowBox[{"{", + RowBox[{"Automatic", ",", "None"}], "}"}]}], ",", + RowBox[{"FrameStyle", "\[Rule]", + RowBox[{"Directive", "[", + RowBox[{"Thick", ",", "20", ",", "Black"}], "]"}]}], ",", + RowBox[{"PlotLabel", "\[Rule]", + RowBox[{"Style", "[", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{ + "WFT", "\[LeftDoubleBracket]", "1", "\[RightDoubleBracket]"}], + "<>", "\"\< MAE: \>\"", "<>", + RowBox[{"ToString", "[", + RowBox[{"SetAccuracy", "[", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"Mean", "[", + RowBox[{"Abs", "[", + RowBox[{"DeleteCases", "[", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"MAE", "\[LeftDoubleBracket]", + RowBox[{";;", ",", "1"}], "\[RightDoubleBracket]"}], ",", + "\"\<\>\""}], "]"}], "]"}], "]"}], ",", "3"}], "]"}], + "]"}], "<>", "\"\< eV\>\""}], ",", "20"}], "]"}]}]}], "]"}], + "\[IndentingNewLine]", ",", "\[IndentingNewLine]", + RowBox[{"SmoothHistogram", "[", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"DeleteCases", "[", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"MAE", "\[LeftDoubleBracket]", + RowBox[{";;", ",", "1"}], "\[RightDoubleBracket]"}], ",", + "\"\<\>\""}], "]"}], ",", "Automatic", ",", "\"\\"", ",", + RowBox[{"PlotRange", "\[Rule]", + RowBox[{"{", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"{", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"-", "2.2"}], ",", "2.2"}], "}"}], ",", "Automatic"}], + "}"}]}], ",", + RowBox[{"PlotStyle", "\[Rule]", + RowBox[{"Directive", "[", + RowBox[{"Black", ",", + RowBox[{"Thickness", "[", "0.01", "]"}]}], "]"}]}], ",", + RowBox[{"Filling", "\[Rule]", "Bottom"}], ",", + RowBox[{"PlotTheme", "\[Rule]", "\"\\""}]}], "]"}]}], + "\[IndentingNewLine]", "}"}], ",", + RowBox[{"ImageSize", "\[Rule]", "300"}]}], "]"}]}], "\[IndentingNewLine]", + RowBox[{ + RowBox[{"Export", "[", + RowBox[{"\"\\"", ",", "%"}], "]"}], ";"}]}], "Input", + CellLabel->"In[64]:=",ExpressionUUID->"31fd4aa9-bc03-4d09-8e5a-c1a6e87694ae"], + +Cell[BoxData[ + GraphicsBox[{{ + {RGBColor[0.92, 0.488, 0.2432], EdgeForm[{Opacity[0.567], Thickness[ + Small]}], {}, + {RGBColor[0.92, 0.488, 0.2432], EdgeForm[{Opacity[0.567], Thickness[ + Small]}], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{-1.2, 0}, {-1., 0.07547169811320754}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{71.49000000000002, 84.95000000000002}, { + 57.293578568398516`, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.07547169811320754]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.07547169811320754"], + StyleBox[ + "0.07547169811320754`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.07547169811320754, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{-1., 0}, {-0.8, 0.1509433962264151}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{84.45000000000002, 97.91000000000003}, { + 40.28106247807825, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.1509433962264151]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.1509433962264151"], + StyleBox[ + "0.1509433962264151`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.1509433962264151, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{-0.8, 0}, {-0.6, 0.4339622641509434}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{97.41000000000003, + 110.87000000000003`}, {-23.51587286062278, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.4339622641509434]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.4339622641509434"], + StyleBox[ + "0.4339622641509434`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.4339622641509434, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{-0.6, 0}, {-0.4, 0.2830188679245283}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{110.37000000000003`, 123.83000000000003`}, { + 10.509159320017773`, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.2830188679245283]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.2830188679245283"], + StyleBox[ + "0.2830188679245283`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.2830188679245283, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{-0.4, 0}, {-0.2, 0.4528301886792453}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{123.33000000000003`, + 136.79000000000002`}, {-27.769001883202847`, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.4528301886792453]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.4528301886792453"], + StyleBox[ + "0.4528301886792453`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.4528301886792453, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{-0.2, 0}, {0., 0.7547169811320755}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{136.29000000000002`, + 149.75000000000003`}, {-95.81906624448393, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.7547169811320755]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.7547169811320755"], + StyleBox[ + "0.7547169811320755`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.7547169811320755, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{0., 0}, {0.2, 0.7735849056603774}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{149.25000000000003`, + 162.71000000000004`}, {-100.07219526706402`, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.7735849056603774]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.7735849056603774"], + StyleBox[ + "0.7735849056603774`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.7735849056603774, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{0.2, 0}, {0.4, 0.5283018867924528}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{162.21000000000004`, + 175.67000000000004`}, {-44.78151797352311, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.5283018867924528]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.5283018867924528"], + StyleBox[ + "0.5283018867924528`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.5283018867924528, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{0.4, 0}, {0.6, 0.5283018867924528}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{175.17000000000004`, + 188.63000000000002`}, {-44.78151797352311, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.5283018867924528]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.5283018867924528"], + StyleBox[ + "0.5283018867924528`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.5283018867924528, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{0.6, 0}, {0.8, 0.4528301886792453}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{188.13000000000002`, + 201.59000000000003`}, {-27.769001883202847`, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.4528301886792453]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.4528301886792453"], + StyleBox[ + "0.4528301886792453`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.4528301886792453, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{0.8, 0}, {1., 0.24528301886792453`}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{201.09000000000003`, 214.55000000000004`}, { + 19.015417365177903`, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.24528301886792453`]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.24528301886792453"], + StyleBox[ + "0.24528301886792453`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.24528301886792453`, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{1., 0}, {1.2, 0.18867924528301888`}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{214.05000000000004`, 227.51000000000005`}, { + 31.77480443291811, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.18867924528301888`]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.18867924528301888"], + StyleBox[ + "0.18867924528301888`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.18867924528301888`, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{1.2, 0}, {1.4, 0.018867924528301886`}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{227.01000000000005`, 240.47000000000003`}, { + 70.05296563613872, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.018867924528301886`]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.018867924528301886"], + StyleBox[ + "0.018867924528301886`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.018867924528301886`, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{1.4, 0}, {1.6, 0.03773584905660377}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{239.97000000000003`, 253.43000000000006`}, { + 65.79983661355865, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.03773584905660377]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.03773584905660377"], + StyleBox[ + "0.03773584905660377`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.03773584905660377, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], "Tooltip"]& ], + TagBox[ + TooltipBox[ + TagBox[ + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.5], + TagBox[ + DynamicBox[{ + FEPrivate`If[ + CurrentValue["MouseOver"], + EdgeForm[{ + GrayLevel[0.5], + AbsoluteThickness[1.5], + Opacity[0.66]}], {}, {}], + + RectangleBox[{2., 0}, {2.2, 0.07547169811320754}, + "RoundingRadius" -> 0]}, + + ImageSizeCache->{{278.85, 292.31000000000006`}, { + 57.293578568398516`, 74.80609465871879}}], + "DelayedMouseEffectStyle"]}, + StatusArea[#, 0.07547169811320754]& , + TagBoxNote->"0.07547169811320754"], + StyleBox[ + "0.07547169811320754`", {FontFamily -> "Times"}, StripOnInput -> + False]], + Annotation[#, + Style[0.07547169811320754, {FontFamily -> "Times"}], + "Tooltip"]& ]}, {}, {}}, {{}, {}, {}, {}, {}, {}, {}, {}, {}, {}, {}, \ +{}, {}, {}, {}}}, {{}, GraphicsComplexBox[CompressedData[" +1:eJztm+VXVV3UtykRUUIpRRBQUEAkBBHUm3kAQaQVpEQBRaRDESkFKaVTkO4G +KQlBWHR3d3d3x3ueMZ7nf3g/sL+ccY3fGmvvc8Y+a8754WJ6Y/L8HR4ODg4j +IQ7O/3yGBP/PhVuK879XTGefk6L2Hvo/Lo+JkrOW30MJ7214fYPFYcz0PW3U +oz2UdSNUV+eLBOAC51QV6x7i4NUTsXWSBEaSrYwFyj2kE38pgTpLGjADRdYX +cffQjJWHr+oZOdBIdhC7v7SLPgp4qi+UyYPd56fkr/p2EQ6Vt7IgzXOIECMf +cKjaRfj/NOlvOClACUVPfFLWLiJIjK8KOvcChsbCTZvDd5HIrzPrD5OV4ChD +++Gm6y6qw9kcfqCtAnRfbxPSWuwioxEMMfMjNXgkvd4Kb3aR+me2sM931UGd +9m/oO9ldpCCwkzgh8RpsZu103B/sooZysTsvMZoQkifOk3VzF20cPWtcMdKC +QieSw+5Lu6gER5NlNP0N9D/vrD483kGwWqHHhasNe4yhvtcXdhDG/G57uO47 +uLyipS7Rs4MuexZHPpnSAYFi1lvGFTtIRXeEbvizLqi4r6z5Z+ygCX53ZMOk +D59V8/79Dd1B50wp7uFPGEDgrS/fR77voB6ld8+Di40gb0v0+RnzHfTbkiuY +KtsEuiuI6W9r7iDOaQHj+lFT2PJtm5GX3kFniv776LFtBpSav7ItBHaQtGOc +8AjtR+Dj1PgSxryDqu/nFz+RNQfFQxaJcvIdpESyL/rS9xN8rF+8NHu4jVzj +FqwjJi3A71fOEMncNoJc2R/hEpaQrWOdxNu1jfJzOVQXi62gnU/4o2rZNhKb +HyGnFrOBNTwiIbv0bXTFRvcwc9gWyNuaieKDt1H4Vy1mBfevwB35s6PeeRuR +n4Qb17DYg7yResSq2TbyyYkz3CX7BiYPb+hRv95GMsYzea4EDuB1bp73keQ2 +algaIUT4jvC7J/NYi38b8fjbxk2SOEFz/Oe679e30XO/t5RiN5xh6aNQQDrp +NvqXz36J87ELXBA5o9Gxv4Vmme587zX9DhzkjWx701tIGSN5yT/5B0gP+21e +69hCw6/0r8Ytu4JBmip6jLbQTfc99xcYd3CzZnTTT91CX/1y345HeECKxIyi +T9AWIqPRpfYj9oJ66t8MeY5bSI1yWz/B0RvmJs3nB0y2UEti5jiXsw8Q5TzM +xVXfQsXu3M5f5XyB9Rue/S2JLTT4/jrxKKMfSMjVScrwbSHSqAZ94z0/eE/v +Q/WRcQvdO+iof9LnDy4LSqO/Lmwh/68qxj9KAyDhL31qye4m0m35JCKV8ROq +v09+mpzcROmLfLdS4gNh6kUqhrhtE22OeZqVxQYBAfOH89zFmwgzaEIYl/wL +mNcFul8kb6KnN+S2DfOD4XHpSZTNz02kkV365k5TCLz1qjaI/raJzmVEhO/M +h4KDuid/jdEmSlp5zjlGHg4x7Iq4S6qbyDxxwutAKALKd2kbL4lvok7KJ9NK +nyJhrHosUODuJlLOf+mFqxYFOD+TtF5f20TagelBLkdRwPjWhMOJeBPxX/Oj +xsRHA4aHfyd5ewPZEqRR8D2LAY2Tw7KW8Q1UlRbzVgc3Fr42VXhsNW+gj1tm +BwO5sRAR6qZ8tWgDcfksHQQax0GJ3rPrwokbSPX1xyeht+Nh6P7lJR3/DcTJ +VEoztxgPh2dG8j3sNtAXxxcuDtkJQNcZ75BtsIE+3cJ5pWubCI9iDGV6lTeQ +rHasYZhkErw05b18LLqBljxvNVyhTwZrof3xG9wbaPwozn9iIxlCLpSlP6Xb +QCGfHSk2mlOgsP+7pQnRBor7UjH/5Hcq9CXJiv7cXEcXzzMvDvumwa4FFWnR +6DpSHe+tzbNKh8tig72jjetIzGCNuObdbxCgiI0l/LuOhiAsm0QpA5TH9Iw5 +4teR1bekVWGWTLDI4BZ87ruONnnvCvtFZ0Lglx18yy/rSNakq2eTIQvypEqa +w/XW0QezLUudqCzouuIcXPFiHRmH2RdNXM+GzRkp7TnhdSR94mWrl5gNlHmX +uMg411FSf57Zxp0c4HPq2+OjXUcco9+vfM3LAYXnUZVqhOvoSlTQozPCf+AD +43tv+/U1RHNFStG56Q/4Ld9RSxheQ45lMY17L3Mh+98mc2P9GtpO4LzzejEX +2tyKVtby1lDYML3j7695sKriUEgTu4b+M/+rOn0pH8hvPXX+z3sN1fsJuuEm +5wP3Fpn8W5s1VPuzgeMAUwByFd20ru/XkNM8LmdLfwEY+4ZP/VZYQ9mjdNJW +Fn/BS0M7sxPW0HG7p8AWRSH8vnPbZv/2Guo+3GcXyimEpoM1McbLa+jXuNeo +vGIRLNUVkIsTrKGPSllfb+4UwYVfdgMGq6tIcGIt5l/oP+DQEU/wHVxFNx/E +LV0QKQZpPhKz/NpVxPlnsoJyvhgM8DofDv1ZRZ6pYspN/iXg1hpCiB+9ikJv +JvziBQQpEVptrJ6rKESN2U54EUG9IWuYrNUqulOYHmslUwpzD1Z0zN+tIvTy +mVJ0fCkQncvjCXm2in7NGhf/PC4F1h7bQ/TfKroyrByooFIGEvGiNVNsq0i6 +8dWZvuwyeP+R2O889SrCj2hMZyItBxfhNnUevFWkLHGF6LZ+OUgzcMv9HlxB +EnWvPq5Vl4NbUfHk3p8VxDe5E/yBuQLqlaWsxTxX0CxNM0myQwUQbfaS+b5b +QVoSrRd8xypAwkcnfvC/FfR48VDzpnAluHBsPmClXkEpZ7m/a0dXQnXtt9aP +y8toXL5XSxyvCgjekemg6mWURUluW/22Ch7jhh8QRy6jFuYr90aqqsAhnN1X +6fMy0uZu63FjrYZywYKbMXLLyIzlomO5ezXgdIv9W7q1jC6+nmv8ulINmA8d +zwRxlpEkb3ZAgUINfCXVmnHqXUJvbbZ13hfUQEnKsm1r5hKa0zOicaSvhUNx +20t0rksogShUH8+xFh5NnEt6r7WEHD0HaAdna8HaLui/HMElFKgU+eKMXB0U +XmXpOL64hKhpNi6Y59bBbn62ruT8Ihq5/puSjq4eBBQxxz/LF5HIAgv7ukM9 +WKw2+Y+FLKK3c+uqc3P1kOfxku3Ox0VEGumitCXfAJuscyWWUovI2LtL62xB +A/BVWShW3lhEaTVDFpcYGuGDFsE82eECyhvqjSJ0aYTsI1+7l50LSF7vKlfX +YiOsBjNQJaYtIEFNQ01jhSbg5k9PWXdaQM1ayRcq/zaBcfsDjNArbB4VRFjO +0Ay/jWu7XO8toNxwJjcV52ZYJFYy6CJZQIGi8SYW883AkTiBwzQ9j5pTb7gQ +y7WAvqhZoGHJPIqSCaPCy2mBlJHj2wWB86gl3R3/5vlWmLXxKMM3mUc3Bg4+ +6j9qBdbLtMpyT+ZRhMWMtJhRK+j8SVwMYZhH4VfZdNPDWyFB/p7D9M4cAk2S +9OCmVphcLKe52zqHpARqNnCOWoHZVT79S9IcMpa4J9J/uw3esAyL1NnPIQU8 +vDw6tTaIKTPopVSdQ5tGeN/R9zYYfbVnpMkzh/78d1Gy8E8bMO674Kedm0MP +F2jHCcba4HUgZfDO2CxaLd5+EXShHSLuxnCKFs4iidaWWb377TDYzFXp5TeL +hrqoAj9ptQOdQbFqv/4salyWuZnj1g5qZ6VWWERnkUDmYSxdTjuExPY6mV2d +RcWNZV6p/e3QDzq0xRszqL6zvl0NtwMuD25kEDXOoBO2hwkstzpAxfKbmGLc +DMqkcaMhku6AQEqygUjbGWREJ1VxZNIB3ZlhpguKM2gthVqWwL8DKGXYCe/f +mUEmrkmtl3M7QHEuP9ThzAzqvNon9KC7A/ycxXiah6aRpk3J+ffbHdDO1FF9 +JW8a1RTUS0VSdQJ5iab6O69pZN6e6TrB2wnyastrmTrTSPB84P17zzrBa9vm ++6HQNPKzY2MNNOqEZr9z9BI00+hH652sc66dcIErKNt/ZQqR2xe1+sV2gnQD +s8RIzRSSc7loxV/cCW7vs4fYo6aQr7njq72uTqjHx3y0sJxCDLq0sWNLnUAU +1URULj+FpEi21rYIukDi0csIErYp1Klrsvbf1S5w6Z3lVcWdQhZOBsFl3F1Q +bW5RF9c3iVYNTOncxLqA4CKBxmrWJDq7XVsVpdoFj9N9Nx+6TaIzMre6yIy6 +wOEpg9v3N5Mo8QMV/7hdF5RPpTF0PJhEWiaU3Df8ugDH4UHuNYpJpP9LYn84 +tgsw12ol9RcmkINcwLvruV3wtfDFaG7FBHp3n99jv6oLSpQmPuGGTaChPPsb +5t1dcLhuel7GfAKp/RRIDZ/ugkfex1G/pCdQIMmesvN2F1jf9uCfZJ5Ahk94 +jwUJu6Gw5koj19E48rTEvVdP1Q27bxO1bLrGEU+9eJAYSzcI4NzbqU4fR3fJ +rdsK+brBIqzc45LLOHrh6bos+Lgb8gTkr79+PY4EMFE7bQrdsNk5lJ/MP47y +mX2r/N52A5+ZgcwW6ThiOqFZdv/YDR9I9sYxM2PIJ1FapsmxG7KTXSw90Bj6 +VkGc/y6gG1bFKEl7g8ZQUFb/X+34buAej469YTqG8GgxRn153WD8lUvQRGIM +5YhRbbbXdsNv2uLmQsYxxBwupq0x0A2LeZLahHujyHlZhcVzuRs4FHr3nrWN +orsvva7r4/WA/so77/DkURQtGLqJT9MDKe4bzHPfRhGrqP2n9xw9MHvrWyGf +2ijiK/P9EC3SA6yVpPL2d0cR/rmUnGLVHtDRDJtqIB5FVtKXr9Wa9YD0nsI2 +Z/UIonzL8qjBrQdqeUyYqi1GkBxloFJbXA9I6LtJv7o1gq6kb4tOoh6ojIn/ +vNkzjAaPqnBJBnvg8UBpjPuPYVTDoounuNcDpRSDTdcFh5EF/SPaMppewEjv +7P6dG0I9nZfuvbzfC/+cLjE/CxlCqQXeKqwqvfCo+I7crOQQqplW4Oe07oWC +LQlru4NB9L0xMMYsvBcEOLXjqdMGkc+P5NTtsl74o2PXmq4+iKpsTD+UzvQC +X2TIwWOSQWQxRhrdRtoHmT25NweLB1BK0UD17ft9wE3e9uyj8QCaUt4ma9Xs +gzSJRVtihgFUJtruUOLeBxzfziZFt/SjT/dSLuzk90HS3+sdAvb9qMJHKPDz +VB+wrv933MLdj6qzeS2EKPshjl2V7f1YH5p58WBC4nE/ML81Vzz27UMcQaI9 +/p/6ISrU2+6nSB/6aaTIT5vUD4ydKSkcG71o/uTJSs9AP4RdqO6qiO1F1MSa +kdXkA0AnNobzUrEXtceJho6KD8CvL4e31wl60f7eofu1rwNwOY9G2TW3B42Q +iTy3yhuAgOW7Dow6PSjveo307MoAUN6STc+n7kHm8Txsb9kHwUdDr1e2phvV +a391G303COS/nPCnP3cjvLtW+0oxg+DRGsn5hbUbTbdElxSNDMKFc0WqlH1d +KJZfmZng2hD8EO52SnXtQqlih0fMr4aAyHotQ+RBF9LScpq6FD4ETtkXBvrm +O1EKXWB82dAQECzcIjQL7UQiI+RlzAzDYH9DlIdIuhNxfexN59IaBhz11+qR +hx1oxy1evyt2GGwDrL7zp3egvKKUWqKZYThsDMhuetWB2uGB8D/2EbA8kzmk +TdqBfEg8uMaNR2D3vwaiw5J29PasVq1hzgiYW0zz+pu0IwsbXHHZ3RHY/I2r +wc7YjuzU6u/9uzYKpjN0bmWtbUiHrSvRWHgUVhkEclW+tSEfIUe1+9qjYKii +MLrC04Zuo3vmZN9HYdHH+Pz38VZUq7/uu5I8Crp1rvzX/FuR9JTBcGvjKMzi +xmvlirYimQ0rvbSVUag1t78SPNuCHMaUdGwujUHtVJ5JzdMWJPHO9ID/3hiU +Ki1VbaU0o4jtvoheZSzX3KBjvtCMAq6SmKhaj0GBgNqH50ZNiIDj862cMCwn ++9TaNzeiXnb85yMlY5BJW3Mtg6sRPV+mr+8ZxbL7kfmQTwNaCL7zIxBvHJIO +eRvOr9ejg8zdNCpmLBvpMz1QqEehDg3OcmLjEDUc9Vn3Tx3acBxME9LBslxP +UyBVHcqhtvUdchmHX6UkzFUWtSgpFO/BrUQs8zy23uipQbYCJpnUNePgE2Pd +yiRYgwKOVTQSp7FMkXVTPqQaEZ+n/tV5ZgJ+OM3Yfj2oQj9unjsIZsbyFn1H +mnoVkuqudtkQmQB7HUW2geJKNGlOoDqkieUeN7tzDJVI09GgSuHrBFhKlHXd +t69ApeXurxRCsfx357bOWDnSmaFs682fAFN2TocAkXL0iz2PaawDy6HaveWx +ZajCbeGz3gqWL4RyrhGUocv4uhQmxJOg+6XNiUGnFFHml9qsME9C6yBZXqgX +Qp1OgZqzQpNQWmL7Zle+BA36s68qq2A5ao70BUUxUnMm7nhoNgmZDkpFWV1F +aNwgR9nPFcvaFe9JfxWiv2LvOlWjJyFKnJvSQO0v+u/fdplPAZZZw0tr6AoQ +9aDr33stk+BDTGzEPJKHXrwj/fZkCsuLFle+Reci79sPUeX+JNg3T1QNvf2D +yLTfZaSRTYF9pvyHBzdzELvZyvbRjSkw9Su+FjSbhVZmvXrz72PZnL1hIyUT +mV/YetEnOQWlaZwrUf2/0duSN4Var7BsSiShppGGancyb8ibTEEU33gUxWQy +Gp6SXoi1x/Ju0V6jbiJiKwkTUffF3u/fz+cuS3EozUzRyjIay/YmqfAhBmkH +EI3tZGL3++FHtL4UiTDpayt9CMvk4oXaOyHo/N5kCX0zdv2vPYMenEB0X9Xo +T/kAlhnT6SWJfZE8MG/WzGJZvizC6tYPVEb+Zp5jawpwyuQJSsxtETuRXtUq +zjTglP4XePGeFmq1z4m7dAHLODcHVex0gIJWstWXGsujjxPHrtjBWZptEyNG +LGs9ND1v7QozHhTJcWzTYM+qT+if4wuelHpR/HexHJWnyJgSCH1tSVbXH2D5 +Mn5selQoUCQEarwXxnJtomW4VBRsz45+IJDAMkEzw2R1DIie6y3alcEyZrOa +XSQeaDLvGooqYNmW1tisOBE6ylYSJ5SnobQAQ1UgkAJPDPTjel9ieVPn33FO +GogRR/gyaWCZ2/OtGFcGmJZdLyzWmgbNPNUz4l2ZwHbb5m3aW+x+nYsqc5ey +wXDEnWJJG8vrdmke8jlQ0/35mt07LJNT4HB7/QGqBW7RN//DnAkKHQ25cCJ5 +6Uwgdn2UtGCixbl8OMi0f0mL3S9Kv3H/ypMC6CaBo2VNLP/QkC12+guLI0fH +FK+xnLAerVleCJflxR1d1bDPV+m8hY/zD5jiiFjklbA8fvlp4n/FwHbymFT3 +GZZx0sIkbUqA6iSKtl0Ky9dgdakAQQXjOSJvsWkwvTYXLWFTCu8L4q9FCWE5 +PVuKlrYMXthdkiC8j+VHtlsLBWWAFtXZKjix3CAWWaxcDsPMdhK9LNjvo0b2 +1Hu7HG7LyCY8ocPyXO+65s8KEJh6RE1xCcuWMWF3+Sqh6onX0qOzWD5rKE7Q +UQl2X92Daw6mwCfw3mqXWRVcvBFRl7uCZZaT4ETyavjU9egp8QSW/9SKWmVU +w19ZHY7aLiyL+i1JytZAH1d+yHoN9v1vfxlEt1QDUvvpFJ5/sazFIrzsXos9 +l/z5QlOwvLo8j9jr4KZzdShjKJbtCgJ86+rg4vMoOSb3KcgkdRB6q1sPIdM6 +3NHWWA6XmuU72wAMGoEmcXpY5qDyI0xowM4dTEpcKlguGn7Y+7gRyIsi5cXF +sf8fyaSp5IlGaPjFXLPEi+U+M28bhyYwYk9UYWfCsu5DQRkm7Jxn4u+FQ4rl +HYKJa6XNcI917cwn7HnR6tLssfq6Ba6bzSl7TGOZ6hd/+VELMNTLfZVqx553 +7dyrT2Vb4SfH5Ym84kmYDaaqysbOdQZ4g/c7kibBVGs/+OpSKyxVh5HG+0/C +KuuIsdOjNjh/ZVyI5ys2X60QXXJvg0shN8/Z6mLz/KTLSgNtgGu1Nun6fBIs +7TyXStjboSR0hV/j0STsin8ov2XdDh9kxIRxbmJzUuUgn7p2sPnaSmtGhs27 +HhruXe6A8LEHC7m72PM+nFH4jW4H5D+M8WofmwCcd2eoG/I7gAwnrra+Hptz +zM/znsXOSQbWj2JysPlmMwpT6oSE+lBd9TBsPSnKCTiT0Ak/F0Q8D50mgMjx +l57xVifsZjcQuBhhc8kvQj2Pu4Ceziv/4AU2v/SGAhPQBZtkx0hTaAJ8+sRn +kya6oLCefiX/5gSQR98uvsjbDXhptm74ZNhcl9zP2qEblpylHojvjAM595bO +RFs3kEj1XnYYwdbDnb6H0kzYPpu/8d1fbD28jErIc017oH7Zn2s5A5u7xE7R +l2L73uI2neu/sLnsj0IXsl4441NTr2yPrbdURt4rr3vhr00BlY/uODAOPdNW ++d0L5Evy9Y3y2DyOX7DsqBdkrj40JxPE5oZXSdll+oApJ0pLlQlbz3lxJvzC ++sCzoWI/9dw4sB5M5h8s9MGNkQF9ovUxSCqv89B+2A89jNl9Jv1jwOr2W6vJ +rR8eNT2VnCjH9gvP/Pn5+/th7qCEVDt1DLivWJ6PZBuA8KKiyXV/bD6qPnrW +agBWDx9T+Npi8yThXNPaAbjJ4/0O3mH7EZObbn00g5D1t7juWGYMBO6f1xB5 +PwiYMxJnW/mx+fEKb2reIPTIhor/YcDm1Z1ElIRDUEZRI5hGhO13PP8O2b4Y +gsXi9t6CtVHAvIjInoobApMbxev9/aNQSuf4XXZzCApf3dKhqMTmk+/V80WH +QcH6Hc7bdGx/lSrNw+g/DOeN3VzqA0dB4iMPoev4MLgfE1VI2mPzB9QDazwj +IPyl3GdSbxQk8Q4y1L6NgCdXafwvhVForBtxqmgdAV+clor3/41CosQ4BzX5 +KNjoGbk/v4Xt79IUg+rvj0LrmH6W6sVRYCOvwbXTGIUO8abkg+0RmP8oaMiL +7QvF6H7Pfm0YgdSe1O6Z36Pg99yXVihqBAwfXhMO6x6FKv+FE8FPI3An0idV +/ngU0nOpX36UHIFlPHzqMzfHgOB70I95hhHI0Plk/xf7O3JtXCqP3BoG0/qZ +eaNPY3D7vBmZf8Mw8HCqvbgePgatRXKqldHDsO7biLorx4D82dbyXcthyNkS +YndfHAP24aS8YdlhMFfNCgDKcaAuieKqZhmGe8U3TjYejsM/9WKf2cMh2GYM +1Et6Ow5U55bbRTuHIN+JqFPdfRxOivGTu1OHwHLWWuhizji0a7l9iXAcAkHp +paSq/nEwHvhwK/jlEOxnaFBY402AxH/M/hW8Q1BE0f6Fk30CQi56kF69MAS2 +nx/Pjj+bgBkSgerQyUH4byDveZDVBNhpSINI8SAcC7EVS0VPwP3fjYTEgYOA +YkJv4dRNwPWjN5YrxoNgT0jq92d1AmSTL4QuPRkEYX37Q93LkzCldun3CeMg +4DWv69BjJkHl51Ncxv0BqOB519b2fhJE7mBIJTsGwOlnz0MX70ko51wnskwb +ALG9pwkP8idBOGGUMs55AAhf/SNfGcb2XdHfuGtfD0BNKadNLOEUFPpGvxu+ +PwA/mKOnlDmnYP1OS/Aodv56+oNC/oLSFMzcD5OsnesH4kXnwtIv2L5mX4nC +u7wfGuR2mT/FT8FToTetnKH94JGj783WNAXUxxIa0R/7QYZmaG9ocwrkQy2f +jkr1A6mNnLYftu5pNzwImrrRDy3DZc3ij6dBZzycKPWgD3xE+AQPDKbBS4a+ +kb2jD54lJMRm+E/DcDERnkZKH1wivkKqXTQN/YRTNiLf+qDDyN3y8sQ0cPzF +jqnKfRDQdjTeSDwDe9Nu07icfaB4z1Tm290ZyPAclOrE7wPq4PH8e2ozMJHt +80+krxe6DxWvz3+bAUbV2HkJ7Dn0S7PGIyJ5BpSY5LsmHHpBpVJw53nbDByW +xVWQKfcCLWua1tm9GWh9Ux9ez94L/e7XGosYZ0Ej0a7l4nEPhK348JtKzILD +GxufidYeUFfAj2Y2nYXicMj4L7YHruV/Ot8XNAsrHtE3mD71wDDt7CdPNAvj +S2mdHuI9EPVVbVR4Zha+Hng02dP0gOZ4o+Q26Rw4bv5zOprphuvikJvCPwc/ +eQU8CQq6YTw5i0Hj9RxQcA9fCvreDXEkzG4ULnOAG9LZna/UDdpmgZs16XMw +H0kop8fSDTe7iDRsu+ZAwt7G6fdGF0wL2NRxH81BgG/GqltZFySFYasy8zyM +aIaE4Hl3gS6OZkSw9DzcP+s5eEW9C9i124lkzedhNPy1XRdrF8zXPP6IFzYP +25+s8h9g61Da7fyhvIp5oHltPytb1gmG3mwSBgvz8NL9TQmNZydwboRmM1As +gMLHuBehKp2wrERK3/lgASo6btCN3uiEzEL77z/eLEBc7arm4nIHtt/aWHvk +tgB9Htb3a/52wF2Hd+prWQuw6bxw/rNTB6xP9VTH9y3AeguNHr5cB/x5Ksmj +hrsIw/ZMxx+udIB5+r9QUrZFWDHh6mucaAf+i1yEFfKLYEGa003zux22zaNN +P1sugpIPSdNLy3Yo6KUYuB21CANPsxkiRdrB8pGL2GjNIjTellSZu4CdwqN2 +MwJWFmHIpqoI09MG+/gGtE9pliDlFk9MWnQb/Hs/5HQktARM3MxPeA3bwLZB +biVLZwnuC309N8DfBkJc5ao6XkvwuS9pNRm3DY79+Cpp85Yg/3nZzYTGVijd +TuBsGVqCkRjBkc6gVmy/eCXY8cwyREWsXnv0thVEStzxBe4sA+mvA+NRzlbA +u35stKi4DIoTete9tlqgwtm0N8p2Ge5bltjOeraA09y4yIu4ZRC4VYrpvdkC +YjIv0s81LgOBunaUNravIsyqoSnZWAZHPqm1ALVmqKF84PDh6gocy493Gm81 +wQ/LtMWboivg5p2sv+vTBE8HrykP6K+AmPX4Z/47TUCM8S3z9luB94NhhHfq +sX1dLD7H48IVGLwXNDfyvhE8zloE7o6tAP0bOr9nhI2QcM/cvptgFe4cyjY5 +xjfA9/fpuZmXVyEk+slTS7EG0A2ennfjWIXPfgRBPNP1INHAwPgOswqvBiMX +fn+vB9YjlReguAoSQ3wfVtnq4RyXn9sV3VXoyyR4utVYB/OaDWjDZhU49F/T +F5vWQb0fwVaT9yqo98lniFHVQUrlf+xJsaswN03l7VVYC+7bFhoO+asAnv52 +AZq1YMiaGaDesAratY94lc7WgrTaXB3/yCq0b5Q6tv6uAQ6P6yfkG6tQyDab +iaNcAyQlL/kWCNeg8HumyMRJNSyvBOhV0a7Bn+RYA4vkamhmao6I5FwDm0rt +T3kK1fBb4WynlcgaDHeoiEUdV4G3M+acotIaXPAifsqdUgWm+VZCnPpr4FTC +/UlbqQrk57I/En3Frn8w+UkQvwq4ry4mjfti13cl6KRlVsJFGZbhf/Fr8ITj +jnHh60pY//qaIujvGngz4lprkVRCe2aQhFnTGnwa6uqN+FcB2eOtX6TG1kAP +M0BrZlgB/pTEOSxba0CHwW/soqsAc3HR2ROidaC3jZdvbCoHRUtb+n66dcjy +ynRVsCsHvpTc53+412H78+ALfZ5yoBpc/u71GMvflRXIJ8tgm4S1WFdlHS5U +dvOJBZVBN2itixiuY4ezhEUiqTLIMwu5RW+/DgyF9JzqJ6UQFNuhvuO/Duc/ +GIlh/pSCZdcFv7bEddCU2zzO1SsFlbPiNalF64DDYlJTwlAKAoJ2h84t62AU +a9VRkIbgikEBj+bEOlThNvpdv4pgP2xN58HOOtxPe7lR4lYC/c3sYZTnN2Cn +cmPP/6AYCnG025avbcA7so6EBKNiCL0bTlh3dwM2aBY2j0b/ga1298NY8Q0I +CC+rjnjxD9QDycy+qG2AbIMnj39DETyqlUhQNt6A91QySaMiRUC//22Ax2ED +Orm+xnsVFcLx7SLyC4Eb4HLWgjH2XiEMv9oUm07eAJPFND22rL9Q4n3HprR4 +A6Q6FCdZOP9CZJlOZkjbBtzwj/gRm1YA9huRU+ZTG3DgthWWyFEAmix9tHJ7 +G3DLyN324e98wChfkmcj2QSHZM0VbZ58YHKVcsZn2oR2Fq84jrw8wCtyKhzi +24T8n1a4wY/yYHyxeCVfYhNKzRRkMytzofzaDrOf+iZ4RJj+/CybC7Hy3GqG +ppvA8JM2cbvvDzg56HmLO23CWMpHzbvv/4D2n5hKxl+bQL9oPce5nQOPpwf2 +9lM34R11IeOqSw6wXKbi6kKbEPFysdnqSg4QSspqZ3RsYvvRwPKW9GyYtvke +7DqzCT9XyjI2RLOhOr20+e3BJjhrtujPDGRB4sgevhDZFsjUDrakfsqCHxd5 +BS/f2IL456POwhezQFfU0Hidfwvmuw2WE39ngsSn+NhGyS2YSm+9PCKTCWyJ +w70Jr7cgvzLZsGYoA4j7aEi/fdgCzFK5m/6NDJgnfib60mULqPlIjsINf0P9 +IzfLeyFbkNmy3aL+Nx1SjSvSyX5vAQH+l8HQc+ngEXU4Ple2Ba8FFiWVX6WB +Yfu9y5VdW+B825r+259UkCYwkYmY2wJHE4tMErJUuMOf5GB5tAWvxFV0Vg1T +gFR3LP/5xW0QVkguvNqcDMvBtEscLNuwoBh+ze5uMjQ3KFw/K7gNr4cNmclD +kiDjyEN5THob8KgY4ooIksCHq9qjSHMbPlj7yn38kIidV0/KfppvQ3+Krz7L +RALI+wvsmPzYhkE+14RSpQTgqTLjkAzbhld3LN14m+Lh4k6KFnPmNqyYF703 +FI+HddbJwOOKbfDNyW5WLo+DdjX6xt6ebWCZCCiexsRBtocSbs7CNlixMO0Q +lseCf4k3v+fJNhz+C7uUIBYL5qu1Bu8pdqB590lMZkMMKF7Hixa+tQPnAhR0 +LivGAJ/iw+6rD3dAGpZeNw1HA5WL+flt2R2YmN73LzaIhu38dEzrmx0Q5q8V +7NuPgu656U8pFjvA9Kqd8qJHFORdZUx1ctsBQqJuCiWGKAiSUR19HbED7suf +KO7pRWLnbT8qwewdMHtgNRITFAEqWQ2SFNU74KMhxTRQFw6CEwT2S3078EGR +i7T+JAyuUAnl1iztgOjysdcLwTDYF/88H427C4e1n7WNLUKh3zKTwZZqF55a +qP08zAuBopQ5RSW2XfDgU+fb3g+G0MHrbtz/7ULOhR5SCZFgsCVVR8TPdrHv +yZ2lSY9foI75uTmpvQuGjmNyZf1B8N+HZjZkid2PbPdNx+0goI87qxHssQuW +V4s7ye0D4bgLE/AxahcwV5iOPvf8hOGz1nUyf3ZhV8zj4JDnJyDBnONbtbtA +86E7Lt47ACINFnnxBneBQWjfVW/VH+zDWfQGV3ahQ13ntrSiP2i2vI7Iw98D +0V2PAckiPxDG/dXhQ7MHnzW55A1Y/ICJt43I4PYepNKwkfz28wW8d8RCYrAH +esXCP2nxfWE8UPQjg8IevBq6vppr4QMVtbZJezp7kEkxWHdhwBti93OHOqz3 +IL5+cPhaixc4caxc+u21B8fR0QpldZ6g/ZpV4kfMHpDHteDhNHiAmI/Wlzd5 +e3DrG2v8Zrs7sJSHZD+q3wODdebkrDE3INzsmKEe3gPPOnFfuR1XmGYhoV9b +2wPW8uqFeQpXqFEWf95wZh9s5706A+//gERXu+/xV/bh89FikPGb7/CjqOCf +3Z19IAohaHcLcAHdpbU1VeF9oC7620Tc7AxPGW7f4nuxDzLtJTuEZM7A9kxb +nVRvH076XIRClJ2A2DHcd9Z2HwZvCl8bTXSE+T/d1eU++xD9bPr2wYkDNEyT +HYbF7UNDRPwdAk0HSL38lOdzwT6wLuJu0NR+Aw9JB51njfsgSMD6VEHgGxja +FoXeHt0Hxzc58+2Z9iDze7P1zCb2+SclTXN47OHO6B3C0bMHUMna4Hjdwg5I +L71/WHj1ABi/E128GPIVlkWjTAO4DiAqTQGj3/IFWj71xRuLHsDBrT8U76i/ +QEbipQEJ5QOIb6kvvG9iCz59UuQ3DA7gfvTyW7J+GzA97yx29PUAKHJYX3Mr +28Cz/0qse/wO4FF4YE31tDXwmOxkZCUcgC5/PwG+qzVcjOaeci88gPNA+uOs +kDWst+vR6jQfQCLF5tBVQmtoJ4iVw4wfwPPdzjKdMSvI4R90ot0+AL9XxhUk +rVbgr0tVuHnuEPAnVJk5263APER2pZn+EKTq9bpPZqxAsfE7czLPIUzKCTIl +XbSGe8elqo5ih5A6d7MX5KyBinvf65XqIcQlffYeiLKGbS3eyvtGh5BDeTIQ +SWgD3f6Gexe/HQLT+uUfafY2kF8Vz7kYcAjcTXIq58hsIWhn+G110iH0Klnq +VWbZgiXb5eCof4eQOFxLMaP7BVRePmu2bj2EtZI59098X0HQ0w3/xeQheB/Y +2BtT2sEVVCHAtXsI0zUrD7QJ7GF/9dDo3IUjYEk27v37wx76r/PHTjAcgVwI +nSgvzTcoUjTpLeY9AgZKwYJ/Gd8g1CWJ5NeTI9Df026Reu4AtgVjIh9eHgHd +Tb+46mMHUJ+ntZQ2OYLWJzG2FLmO8B+dYvpNxyNYHHPmovzkBPSynuM4QUdw +LPJ+M17IGY7tqmkGUo5gT8yKK/qiCwxnnUjnlhxBF8eIcN+SC6AJAQfv9iPQ +e8KiTtfxHSKpPuTrTR8Bc3qFAm/ZD7B/krooun8ECnHU34byXUHTapLpGukx +sErtfhrNcwPhVHrlXaZjCIs917ta7A5MQ0oe7feOYboSjlGjB+CR+ZSlPT2G +9s8fH26Me8I4pm7b5dUx4LU+bHqE4w0VH/A4tMyOYczy+nn6Sz4QG/dQ66Hz +MVx0qr4jnOgDTt3mgVTBx3A7srNTEXxBm+h3w0raMTCZcRAz9PuC2IMZnPrS +YxD5rDD19rMfsBgy8sd1HkOTnk7wJLU/EEaoGnydPYZUZYLvGgX+MN3iF6Vy +eAwmruLPfV4GQA1uY9dd8hOIH2w75ML5CYm8Z86TMJ9AbPhZgq34n/DjnRBm +5v4JKO4pOvpLB4Ju0OdPZVInkIEXrFa8EQhP6zJTQjVOAE9QR5YxNAjYDuZG +Pn08gbWeq3V6Ir+A+M4NKvnvJ+AxO4YrM/cL5l+rS7KHnkAg3WSPkXcwNPj8 +tCPIOIHlyC/XbflCILW8+c9w+Qncn/8rQdcbAh6bZ+cLuk9A9CEv4bZVKBje +FGbwnz+BCltN/8wrYSCjYq1odHwCpVeK59fzwoC6qq/yxjkcjGf4LXLtZ+Fw +9rXFCDkFDuZZ+A211Nlw2Nm+tH9Eh4PZkk74Z2obAbPeGZQLN3EwI67kVK8u +REIvqzRXLzcOJv7algXtr0ioLZt9WvUAB7OpEPsohSwKCtSctbMf42CMxsuF +B+WjIGmDyS5SFgfznF6UxMY7Cn55lAR7qOBglO9yB2o0RIEry8s/Vm9wMIfD +vne0CaLBqmSnWccQB3OtfCVG+0E06CsHzClY4GA08hreCxlFg9oqN4GwPQ6G +m3w4qzUsGiRdm65xuuFgRAdHQw9ro+HBdX3BqwE4mD99BY/j16KBvYhQkSgC ++3yLjYsZ1DFAqxhrvJWIg1Fl1LhIIBAD55fAdTwLBwP7/5zdX8TAgfNgbEsR +DuZhauQxj0kMLF6zKvlXhYNJEMtqnHaKgcF8qr7kFhzMzVG5ldDAGGiUz94I +7MPBvH8mnPI4Lgb+zcmSOk3gYDCIIK4nPQbSHBZYzZZwMBEVQg9lc2Ig7OoP +0dc7OJjHxM884/7EgOcf5tdSuLiY1IA9q76sGPgiU2YpcB4XM026EbucEgPG +06/8WahwMZlSAcazkTHw2m4//RIDLkYhxWy3yScGZC8H1Z6w4mJKO89SJH+J +AaEs3onFu7gYTJ/NfRedGOCUbD3qe4SLecj+zdJcKgauTRherhHHxcTpW5s5 +c8QAme053j/yuBgK1uW7Tedi4IQyQSZaDRdDmmTI8WYiGlbTRXS9tHExBYVn +KV/9jYZR8REHG2NcTD/pt4Ze92hoHbEJ17XExTg2KImuq0VDqeXlghcO2Pux +9L2svRkNmRdz20U8cDHbshaVNitREJXybIkrEBdzxcywjzM3Cv7Xd8D8n99w +6j+c+g+n/sOp/3DqP5z6D6f+w6n/cOo/nPoPp/7Dqf9w6j+c+g+n/sOp/3Dq +P5z6D6f+w6n/cOo/nPoPp/7Dqf9w6j+c+g+n/sOp/3DqP5z6D6f+w6n/cOo/ +nPoPp/7Dqf9w6j+c+g+n/sOp/3DqP5z6D6f+w6n/cOo/nPoPp/7Dqf/w/7v/ +8P8AUD6mog== + "], {{{}, + {GrayLevel[0], Opacity[0.3], EdgeForm[None], + GraphicsGroupBox[PolygonBox[CompressedData[" +1:eJwl1kPUGIYSBtA/tu2ksW2bjW3btts4jdnYtm3btm0n7+Z1cc/MZmY1Z86X +qGG7im0DBwQEBCJCkICA333EIP/14QlHWMIQmlCEJATBCUZQgvyeJRAB/LLo +Jz/4zje+8oXPfOIjH3jPO97yhte84iUveM4znvKExzziIQ+4zz3ucofb3OIm +N7jONa5yhctc4iIXOM85znKG05ziJCc4zjGOcoTDHOIgB9jPPvayh93sYic7 +2M42trKFzWxiIxtYzzrWsobVrGIlK1jOMpayhMUsYiELmM885jKH2cxiJjP4 +l+lMYypTmMwkJjKB8YxjLGP4h9GMYiQjGM4whjKEv/mLwQxiIAPoTz/60ofe +9KInPehON7rShc50oiMdaE87fh9mG1rTipa0oDnNaEoTGtOIhjSgPvWoSx1q +U4ua1KA61ahKFSpTiYpUoDzlKMuflKE0pShJCYpTjKIUoTCFKEgB8pOPvOQh +N7nISQ6yk42sZCEzmchIBtKTjrSkITWpSEkKkpOMpCQhMX+QiIQkID7xiEsc +YhOLmMQgOtGIShQiE4mIRCA84QhLGEITipCEIDjBCEoQAhOI30/kl4fykx98 +5xtf+cJnPvGRD7znHW95w2te8ZIXPOcZT3nCYx7xkAfc5x53ucNtbnGTG1zn +Gle5wmUucZELnOccZznDaU5xkhMc5xhHOcJhDnGQA+xnH3vZw252sZMdbGcb +W9nCZjaxkQ2sZx1rWcNqVrGSFSxnGUtZwmIWsZAFzGcec5nDbGYxkxn8y3Sm +MZUpTGYSE5nAeMYxljH8w2hGMZIRDGcYQxnC3/zFYAYxkAH0px996UNvetGT +HnSnG13pQmc60ZEOtKcdbWlDa1rRkhY0pxlNaUJjGtGQBtSnHnWpQ21qUZMa +VKcaValCZSpRkQqUpxxl+ZMylKYUJSlBcYpRlCIUphAFKUB+8pGXPOQmFznJ +QXaykZUsZCYTGclAetKRljSkJhUpSUFykpGUJCTmDxKRkATEJx5xiUNsYhGT +GEQnGlGJQmQiEZEIhCccYQlDaEIRkhAEJxhBCUJgAgX6L0z8Un7yg+984ytf ++MwnPvKB97zjLW94zSte8oLnPOMpT3jMIx7ygPvc4y53uM0tbnKD61zjKle4 +zCUucoHznOMsZzjNKU5yguMc4yhHOMwhDnKA/exjL3vYzS52soPtbGMrW9jM +JjaygfWsYy1rWM0qVrKC5SxjKUtYzCIWsoD5zGMuc5jNLGYyg3+ZzjSmMoXJ +TGIiExjPOMYyhn8YzShGMoLhDGMoQ/ibvxjMIAYygP70oy996E0vetKD7nSj +K13oTCc60oH2tKMtbWhNK1rSguY0oylNaEwjGtKA+tSjLnWoTS1qUoPqVKMq +VahMJSpSgfKUoyx/UobSlKIkJShOMYpShMIUoiAFyE8+8pKH3OQiJznITjay +koXMZCIjGUhPOtKShtSkIiUpSE4ykpKExPxBIhKSgPjEIy5xiE0sYhKD6EQj +KlGITCQiEoHwhCMsYQhNKEISguAEI2jA/yN/wP8AXVqEEQ== + + "]]]}, {}, {}}, {{}, {}, + {GrayLevel[0], PointSize[ + NCache[ + Rational[1, 120], 0.008333333333333333]], Thickness[0.01], CapForm[ + "Butt"], LineBox[CompressedData[" +1:eJwl10O0GIYSANAX21ZjNrbd2LZt20Zj23Ya27Zt28a/OX9xz8xmlqOEDdpW +aBMoICAgYpCAgD8xMNKAoAQjOCEISShCE4awhCM8Ef7UE4nIRCEq0YhODGIS +i9jEIS7x+Iv4JCAhiUhMEpKSjOSkICWp+JvUpCEt6UhPBjKSicxkISvZyE4O +cpKL3OQhL/nITwEKUojC/EMRilKM4pSgJKUoTRnKUo7yVKAilahMFapSjerU +oCa1qE0d6lKP+jSgIY1oTBOa0ozmtKAlrWhNG9rSjvZ0oCOd6EwXutKN7vSg +J73oTR/60o/+DGAggxjMEIYyjOGMYCT/MorRjGEs4xjPBCYyiclMYSrTmM4M +ZjKL2cxhLvOYzwIWsojFLGEpy1jOClayitWsYS3rWM9/bGAjm9jMFrayje3s +YCe72M0e9rKP/RzgIIc4zBGOcozjnOAkpzjNGc5yjvNc4CKXuMwVrnKN69zg +Jre4zR3uco/7POAhj3jME57yjOe84CWveM0b3vKO93zgI5/4zBe+8o3v/OAn +v/jNn+YPRGCCEJRgBCcEIQlFaMIQlnCEJwIRiURkohCVaEQnBjGJRWziEJd4 +/EV8EpCQRCQmCUlJRnJSkJJU/E1q0pCWdKQnAxnJRGaykJVsZCcHOclFbvKQ +l3zkpwAFKURh/qEIRSlGcUpQklKUpgxlKUd5KlCRSlSmClWpRnVqUJNa1KYO +dalHfRrQkEY0pglNaUZzWtCSVrTmz/BuSzva04GOdKIzXehKN7rTg570ojd9 +6Es/+jOAgQxiMEMYyjCGM4KR/MsoRjOGsYxjPBOYyCQmM4WpTGM6M5jJLGYz +h7nMYz4LWMgiFrOEpSxjOStYySpWs4a1rGM9/7GBjWxiM1vYyja2s4Od7GI3 +e9jLPvZzgIMc4jBHOMoxjnOCk5ziNGc4yznOc4GLXOIyV7jKNa5zg5vc4jZ3 +uMs97vOAhzziMU94yjOe84KXvOI1b3jLO97zgY984jNf+Mo3vvODn/ziN38W +fyACE4SgBCM4IQhJKEIThrCEIzwRiEgkIhOFqEQjOjGISSxiE4e4xOMv4pOA +hCQiMUlISjKSk4KUpOJvUpOGtKQjPRnISCYyk4WsZCM7OchJLnKTh7zkIz8F +KEghCvMPRShKMYpTgpKUojRlKEs5ylOBilSiMlWoSjWqU4Oa1KI2dahLPerT +gIY0ojFNaEozmtOClrSiNW1oSzva04GOdKIzXehKN7rTg570ojd96Es/+jOA +gQxiMEMYyjCGM4KR/MsoRjOGsYxjPBOYyCQmM4WpTGM6M5jJLGYzh7nMYz4L +WMgiFrOEpSxjOStYySpWs4a1rGM9/7GBjWxiM1vYyja2s4Od7GI3e9jLPvZz +gIMc4jBHOMoxjnOCk5ziNGc4yznOc4GLXOIyV7jKNa5zg5vc4jZ3uMs97vOA +hzziMU94yjOe84KXvOI1b3jLO97zgY984jNf+Mo3vvODn/ziN3+O/kAEJghB +CUZwQhCSUIQmDGEJR3giBPn///A/0nOEEQ== + "]]}}}], {{}, {}}}}, + AspectRatio->NCache[GoldenRatio^(-1), 0.6180339887498948], + Axes->{False, False}, + AxesLabel->{None, None}, + AxesOrigin->{-2.2880000000000003`, 0}, + BaseStyle->14, + Frame->True, + FrameLabel->{{None, None}, { + FormBox["\"Error (eV)\"", TraditionalForm], None}}, + FrameStyle->Directive[ + Thickness[Large], 20, + GrayLevel[0]], + FrameTicks->{{None, None}, {Automatic, Automatic}}, + GridLines->{{0}, {0}}, + GridLinesStyle->Directive[ + GrayLevel[0.5, 0.4]], + ImageSize->300, + LabelStyle->{FontFamily -> "Times"}, + PlotLabel->FormBox[ + StyleBox["\"CASSCF MAE: 0.47 eV\"", 20, StripOnInput -> False], + TraditionalForm], + PlotRange->{{-2.2, 2.2}, {All, All}}, + PlotRangePadding->{{ + Scaled[0.02], + Scaled[0.02]}, {None, + Scaled[0.05]}}, + Ticks->{Automatic, Automatic}]], "Output", + CellLabel->"Out[66]=",ExpressionUUID->"6388ff56-ba75-4aa8-9483-c26182754d88"] +}, Open ]], + +Cell[CellGroupData[{ + Cell[BoxData[{ RowBox[{ RowBox[{"WFT", "=", @@ -24998,8 +25856,8 @@ b5JAxM18hw2qT5rnrVWF88HuEdCA89HzC4wPAHciYt4= }, Open ]] }, WindowSize->{1440, 847}, -WindowMargins->{{1441, Automatic}, {Automatic, 0}}, -FrontEndVersion->"13.0 for Mac OS X ARM (64-bit) (December 2, 2021)", +WindowMargins->{{Automatic, 126}, {Automatic, 0}}, +FrontEndVersion->"13.0 for Mac OS X x86 (64-bit) (December 2, 2021)", StyleDefinitions->"Default.nb", ExpressionUUID->"85b7a10d-2875-445d-bac3-ec6fc5ce6624" ] @@ -25028,43 +25886,47 @@ Cell[2603, 70, 89, 0, 98, "Title",ExpressionUUID->"7bca69e7-ea88-42f1-8cb1-a3017 Cell[2695, 72, 245, 5, 46, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"717b96b6-16dc-49c5-8f1c-5691e5e5da0f", InitializationCell->True], Cell[CellGroupData[{ -Cell[2965, 81, 5142, 122, 304, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"919b4508-e93a-4c58-acbd-bccf8883719c"], -Cell[8110, 205, 126303, 2334, 531, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"015b06bf-1e91-4e1a-9cff-a6bd49cc491b"] +Cell[2965, 81, 3811, 94, 262, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"31fd4aa9-bc03-4d09-8e5a-c1a6e87694ae"], +Cell[6779, 177, 35282, 757, 272, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"6388ff56-ba75-4aa8-9483-c26182754d88"] }, Open ]], Cell[CellGroupData[{ -Cell[134450, 2544, 1392, 34, 94, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"f9587fd2-1e23-4030-9f68-19ee3273f3fd"], -Cell[135845, 2580, 910, 23, 34, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"ddd7a8f9-59bf-40aa-b7d9-bc4f1657909d"] +Cell[42098, 939, 5142, 122, 304, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"919b4508-e93a-4c58-acbd-bccf8883719c"], +Cell[47243, 1063, 126303, 2334, 531, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"015b06bf-1e91-4e1a-9cff-a6bd49cc491b"] }, Open ]], Cell[CellGroupData[{ -Cell[136792, 2608, 33857, 784, 1858, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"d3cfcc37-7870-45d8-9dde-1f2d1fb25587"], -Cell[170652, 3394, 1668, 42, 34, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"20eac2ff-49eb-454b-8032-5f9dde62980f"], -Cell[172323, 3438, 965099, 18691, 2059, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"6574969c-81b8-467d-9bfb-ccfcce64c9d4"] +Cell[173583, 3402, 1392, 34, 94, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"f9587fd2-1e23-4030-9f68-19ee3273f3fd"], +Cell[174978, 3438, 910, 23, 34, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"ddd7a8f9-59bf-40aa-b7d9-bc4f1657909d"] +}, Open ]], +Cell[CellGroupData[{ +Cell[175925, 3466, 33857, 784, 1858, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"d3cfcc37-7870-45d8-9dde-1f2d1fb25587"], +Cell[209785, 4252, 1668, 42, 34, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"20eac2ff-49eb-454b-8032-5f9dde62980f"], +Cell[211456, 4296, 965099, 18691, 2059, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"6574969c-81b8-467d-9bfb-ccfcce64c9d4"] }, Open ]] }, Open ]], Cell[CellGroupData[{ -Cell[1137471, 22135, 86, 0, 98, "Title",ExpressionUUID->"a87d4be2-7864-4d6c-a2e3-36b4dcb9831f"], -Cell[1137560, 22137, 244, 5, 46, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"106aeec9-b1fc-431a-b4b9-d3a7cdcac07d", +Cell[1176604, 22993, 86, 0, 98, "Title",ExpressionUUID->"a87d4be2-7864-4d6c-a2e3-36b4dcb9831f"], +Cell[1176693, 22995, 244, 5, 46, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"106aeec9-b1fc-431a-b4b9-d3a7cdcac07d", InitializationCell->True], Cell[CellGroupData[{ -Cell[1137829, 22146, 4452, 128, 283, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"0f8cc5fb-1a0b-4172-b346-6b0a3699cd11"], -Cell[1142284, 22276, 31728, 630, 318, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"4a3f128c-d621-4a5d-9883-46aa65f2e128"] +Cell[1176962, 23004, 4452, 128, 283, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"0f8cc5fb-1a0b-4172-b346-6b0a3699cd11"], +Cell[1181417, 23134, 31728, 630, 318, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"4a3f128c-d621-4a5d-9883-46aa65f2e128"] }, Open ]] }, Open ]], Cell[CellGroupData[{ -Cell[1174061, 22912, 152, 3, 98, "Title",ExpressionUUID->"adbad97c-5cc1-459d-b662-b85d0910cb88"], +Cell[1213194, 23770, 152, 3, 98, "Title",ExpressionUUID->"adbad97c-5cc1-459d-b662-b85d0910cb88"], Cell[CellGroupData[{ -Cell[1174238, 22919, 3328, 70, 94, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"5d41447f-af63-414c-a72f-279d73505b87"], -Cell[1177569, 22991, 53160, 880, 5156, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"b7b5c954-23f1-476d-83c3-e63def1b3658"] +Cell[1213371, 23777, 3328, 70, 94, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"5d41447f-af63-414c-a72f-279d73505b87"], +Cell[1216702, 23849, 53160, 880, 5156, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"b7b5c954-23f1-476d-83c3-e63def1b3658"] }, Open ]] }, Closed]], Cell[CellGroupData[{ -Cell[1230778, 23877, 150, 3, 72, "Title",ExpressionUUID->"61cd51bf-e012-4d32-bf6d-b9b9c71fc72c"], -Cell[1230931, 23882, 2518, 68, 229, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"ad61fbc1-6c66-408c-8f64-9aeb20e11f88", +Cell[1269911, 24735, 150, 3, 72, "Title",ExpressionUUID->"61cd51bf-e012-4d32-bf6d-b9b9c71fc72c"], +Cell[1270064, 24740, 2518, 68, 229, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"ad61fbc1-6c66-408c-8f64-9aeb20e11f88", InitializationCell->True], -Cell[1233452, 23952, 2761, 73, 283, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"d48b5f18-7800-4eb1-91de-a74892343606"], +Cell[1272585, 24810, 2761, 73, 283, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"d48b5f18-7800-4eb1-91de-a74892343606"], Cell[CellGroupData[{ -Cell[1236238, 24029, 2169, 44, 115, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"88c5defa-ce5a-47a9-9104-0124f20e76a8"], -Cell[1238410, 24075, 47554, 920, 345, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"b7f2b372-fe4a-440e-bb84-c204b0cb3a05"] +Cell[1275371, 24887, 2169, 44, 115, "Input",ExpressionUUID->"88c5defa-ce5a-47a9-9104-0124f20e76a8"], +Cell[1277543, 24933, 47554, 920, 345, "Output",ExpressionUUID->"b7f2b372-fe4a-440e-bb84-c204b0cb3a05"] }, Open ]] }, Open ]] } diff --git a/Manuscript/CASPT3.tex b/Manuscript/CASPT3.tex index e7d8b0e..8043cf3 100644 --- a/Manuscript/CASPT3.tex +++ b/Manuscript/CASPT3.tex @@ -159,8 +159,8 @@ We underline that, although a third-order version of NEVPT has been developed \c \end{figure} %%% %%% %%% %%% -For each compound represented in Fig.~\ref{fig:mol}, we have computed the CASPT2 and CASPT3 vertical excitation energies with Dunning's aug-cc-pVTZ -basis set. \cite{Kendall_1992} +For each compound represented in Fig.~\ref{fig:mol}, we have computed the \alert{single-state} CASPT2 and CASPT3 vertical excitation energies. +\alert{All calculations reported in the present manuscript have been performed with Dunning's aug-cc-pVTZ basis set.} \cite{Kendall_1992} Geometries and reference theoretical best estimates (TBEs) for the vertical excitation energies have been extracted from the QUEST database \cite{Veril_2021} and can be downloaded at \url{https://lcpq.github.io/QUESTDB_website}. All the CASPT2 and CASPT3 calculations have been carried out in the frozen-core approximation and within the RS2 and RS3 contraction schemes as implemented in MOLPRO and described in Refs.~\onlinecite{Werner_1996} and \onlinecite{Werner_2020}. @@ -501,8 +501,11 @@ TBEs listed as ``safe'' are assumed to be chemically accurate (\ie, absolute err %%% FIGURE 2 %%% \begin{figure} - \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{fig2} - \caption{Histograms of the errors (in \si{\eV}) obtained for CASPT2 and CASPT3 with and without IPEA shift. + \includegraphics[width=0.5\linewidth]{fig2a} + \\ + \vspace{0.01\textwidth} + \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{fig2b} + \caption{Histograms of the errors (in \si{\eV}) obtained for \alert{CASSCF as well as} CASPT2 and CASPT3 with and without IPEA shift. Raw data are given in Table \ref{tab:BigTab}.} \label{fig:PT2_vs_PT3} \end{figure} @@ -658,6 +661,7 @@ The two principal take-home messages of this study are that: (ii) CASPT2(IPEA) and CASPT3 have a very similar accuracy. These global trends are also true for specific sets of excitations and various system sizes. Therefore, if one can afford the extra computation cost associated with the third-order energy (which is only several times more than its second-order counterpart), one can eschew the delicate choice of the IPEA value in CASPT2, and rely solely on the CASPT3(NOIPEA) excitation energies. +\alert{Of course, it is worth stressing that the present conclusions are only valid for small- and medium-sized molecules and that the present study does not cover transition metal complexes.} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% \section*{Supplementary Material} diff --git a/Manuscript/fig2a.pdf b/Manuscript/fig2a.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d28ab14d47fe829182e4625c9ef041af02e1be1d GIT binary patch literal 20847 zcma&N19W8D)&?5eb}F`Q+qP}nwr$%^Cmna(vC(nI>agRNKIfkM-yd(hS5>R_o?4iD z?=ilw<|;BpQE@sZdNvrcwu|}~7*+ryz`@uWhL;z>AZuoC;c5wB`&22z00006aVuL_ zGw08vt&yvlsF{g_sTmAEKa7j3vzd_{jA!nJo=gLql+)&8!!a4{;r#t+ga?+9j3n(j zwpWN20Jm{gEPWLAy_bc!xvQq;+1Eq!1!_QcxQ<^>FTq#ToXkl7TwojgrJ(WXN#LFP zZKl;X^~?LC!H3uTFk$-B%!iHTnAiJ8>-WB7akCJ9~$RlWzQNBbmo zRtUdH2&~?JCEOOg0^?e?Ci%_bl1Sl5XoYoAPT1MNp8@t=vh)1-)#L3j3_zPPA`8y~keh zJCpuzNRC~`zgH*LzWCy8Ecd+Q_DpL8w9H(uH#Vi%t=(5DoVP1e-8HGlS`&2=aBP1jWUHCCza#~ zXXw%o`Q5zF7;TKpE=ucu(c?(njqF>pasS}pjk!MlhX%MPR72fFzTHP`p$*UXB9V!i?LEK#B2O| z?K#Q@wzyYu$`l}UgaXdj?)11pEkn%*QBb`rg+B|mL7GdWNhxh|2w!^>e>#3ESQmJ3 z%K@XS5wSrKeW2q^4k6f>Dn}M3gCj**<&S6kj+#Wq*-FOOb`e2hwuWEjXF7w`Y!@$B zCr{V9E^}%!oU~-hmsIi~m4nDFD#6Htqcoq9Rg1uHtwTn1wwr)Iob(lAO5y?~g@C)A zm8*5<+^G7#{(BPgDjwy}*_&^BlG5G~;rmCTl(gQ|=J1Sbsb@_G21&L|?nFM$q!MpP z4`2afvPB{Ss=g;AVMK}doOoL5M5ENAwrk^9r4-~y~oJslA5Lc1BQw3nWP2_W)1*TVK5WcfKu;Fso`KJf&HM;4^J0pJ|O#E-v(QBgOZ&l^aiLtU_D_P7GrXAL~*;7%$K| zJ73l3ey!>uc5*wQj5kCG#k)04)GB;&&P_zJ)g&57LOSd2JbsxzAu|@q1FKUt#=1Yv zGnN$wIkM$oYCqYx(b2Z}DPY$PDm_49xoeTh*NW*jQAM0dO+TWPRLHfch1gveAf-Lf zS&x8jaCd&ud7?4s%-L)j=Ro!BtO-%mzEBirjkJWqp64D+L}WE1r5nNbC7#MZ87|Vh z9L!EtMD}b<^rj&iZC;R+F;EiTs5FN}S;W1)ksX!jq(~S#Qa*@eKPnbM@@RGCcmdNo z)7lZL=_EaHtd}$9EX6n8qKLl;iOBFWr8R0wa0`FnS6QHDXK7%mysSQ1um6UgO6HuC zs%SLP92f>j4icZLB}@q#v?wk{g&<3;^LUloZ1<~NfgISAA5K#`(;51YjRb8<1-W7>t$N&DiK z4l@EdbK=wcwgZ&%+`Vgre}A)oP;dsAbmJ!b*$0Pq5WVk(ZJ`65I}>HrwvJy5;?Cm> za*<0=Zo>cKGaMuCM}rBxPjuuE7@P?q;=B^Po{>@djn@+w>jl8lYQ3O?BN%MfI|Mm|nx5r#@-xmsmUVbUH+n9oRZ z4y>*QO)Ofu2bG9A9PNpd8=Wc~?PL_13R(bd^BPEa$`DE(Er3#nCG$#&$IL3+b5Tv7 zO&idQXOoN**)4w~8X4XHc~fsiMFZ?}jfhmikQV@?Hzd1B&JPsAXfMbzrB{f~3&mC+ zYF8a{ZndJpsbNH`W=vlga|0D8a8qqCCpVbtf|Pl=&BjRNeERk=!$@Hh-F>q;gQ6wZO;&0UHQ|Qtl6l*C0fu z8bK*DrU38?6swU~0)_bxtm9INlL+MZr;t{gAyUa)df|#h5l?)5(s7YD$sq)z2!z>4 zq|-5t#)y&CQ9{2?WpHuUAjAl{lE68oSwMw-^WW*A~Y&{yZoy(9`+J8{GQD}&9vsI{QLvB6$ zNj-o>h2$KPLNAcd_@b5sf-V2h&jT`y+J_0;C~_;S67HeL+UnSN^(+L{{L31%;r6FPY42He+$(l)5QL z-R`>-=oDbk-|@y_Kmk@$l~F<4*$C2RniNXWTvh~zv87YMuIz$aL~2!e`Yp`v@IQbg zOD z%x7HRtK+Pwp;-{(2ueU3O9o=jBC~~=i+F&c`8A(n%2j_Zfd&e)>1mP*%i;><mz$FLK4-{6-#cCEVI^Swvr-eI;Xe~CxC^lJH z#JYLyUPZU+3O=z66PDZuWQQGFwWcl@T62X(X}SYi;mM0hr8eE=1sAAEd*|XQlx$-5 ztIIgJU{?MObAe^3I7x=C;)$#;diXn zXz-QfjW+zi8n9e33%Hn_ijWV!oyr0h@Pt~t3p=Sj_o)-pFk%#JjLty_Fp?Hyr<*K%AauTb zj};K@HCTlPs2-Ioyd%pHkPi6jy!M7*v0*q>kIc8hE=DRi741pG{z3QTI6PB2ky$+S zK*ezMIz9-O14f?yM72@S0VN*HLaqCzES}YMrNb~_#;-;yGKV;Z#2fkTyAUc3!LYvok3Q>rze9cJ2_-tLFH9-L< zz@~)S2LpkksclFgVtj$?BPiu6qyv%C-o>69?AN0G5jbOZz^iQWVJ$H$(&~dF(Rfun zh(cXBB9JMhU?V)e@+z&Ay+K!q=z;tLXkkOZ$EdQzS{gv?KDjMlm+5C2HK9L}@83Pnv012r{Nni)M$q!qMtzUyGSCIlbEf{s9 zFs>=41S5GhB0(GjiRN8)Ar6tV*mP3l$5?>g*vEr^|;byF)-{ zX`owuoB)OiRX*j(QpBWSf6WE8wNxYq&b+9R*?jA6oQqjR59@|Xwozt z`nB*>!-hkLKzPv17|BuQC+jVY9i%gL@NrP`niGD=Jb4P3lR!CU&CP9~Bv?C9uNGb?9iCV(%mL+A?5?rm80UM&`&1uT!O zr&p)e#*K+l**oAhUNIJ@Eeilwt581b+0DvbqaZq{bYBvfbE$jNHnPF=@PiiG!moaj zLG+qDdy)#Pc8}x6UjAm^Ue0=z#Fc18H{BlG&`#G@Z*QiJtG#s2`cW)uZe8aMdC)d> zQSF%ebm2-1bzG{2d$SZfT+4B~WNt7K&4aem$ljL9wwoUqlKkjIS=y|Y=f|jQBDc0I zQRw`m5ZS%0NJpr!?%hM@mlX|tQ@?#q>AE3wQ;*frK7$5@f{#laF>NQ*L>GW6_y_E(vf^zrp@*re z5ifQr{;&Lq62dpXapgm=KIeY{h%yJK zV2$y5J+Ei9Dvu7LYTy;lp)S>k{EiJhhQ$&UTF2cia9L=NBTPq$-AK|wJ&6<^QfrM^mC z33oN#N{g9KW%k4+nN5JO7mWaFLF%wU3r7T9W;wtr2mqU|mK}rGzzoGluxePs-e|^v z&6Fu0vY1-b#5LvcDG{!nh;=f z89gA(YnHRleM)&^YyGO<0S5zk{jv{_wJ-zy{uRI=5BQ=0TmNi>ns&@r>^I5}DNHIQ zw>qt&8^!$?2*yPe_Qwtl>}^wTaMEg$u1Iu7Ki2V@(lVG}z1U_;q2n95QkD`QAS?-B zrJkBNMhIWqtoE@-7~*lWsCs6=c=p1)gn7B88?^EDxuLy@d&4jgr-C6;XI0%4r)2G~ zR5v9ouu?DquvqS50K}LzM<5dt3T~^|WDyqB7*af5D6}x3X`Wb&<`V*HECYp$?(OQ! zuKm0KO?m;62M_X96hP}Xw`Ed}XQh$GoxLCcK(kT{HhcP(O17lOWrIaVE;W09C4EK< zN=%6UHb%u3IG3Ed*$%2Q)X0zj1pxLOoJ16D=y)YXB^eYiqr^^IqTI?DoyrEP(QQsg zBX1nJO!%G0#J45~9)gh_L7^Zb_TfxO@C(S!?hq4l5;b!U=3XRksXktn&Y0?aC*_1K zQ3f`?AsSiI;ofX;G3AM)5F8G4kxM79c8nl8>P_&7a2iOo+Q4J;ShG=N3)ENyNN#Z} z%zk#MUE6BRAPod%JX|wBWpec*IB2wSUGsSJkyp^|E<&(C5};(IMXWlm-sfzDIX5mOaU)ZfJoF@UUsYIXI(QdISS{vAZfIQY zpcJ)ot(Y}c70{GSgR>m-QHO?t{e+}OY7_M$l^fMPNb=T51Z$WW@{`GG!U92l)AU-S zG<)8}*xDuf>CQ~OVTHnH@-}k)_~z0|9X^!FXbF}}0%&e>#Ja~N#+yIP(qQA4e-O6w zcHsOKQ;%;-C6nYM+$qtYMT?+F9}>Znxc0p5=NKOeqSC63 zw6%s&Q%&AQr`ZV_K5hwouXop%6?1NcjJ|t}&>dFU;Z?r*XZB3bOWxWu_Tv$9a}GH# zBiZ3okH$XkxSp$f3KfMsltW71oVHU=x#1))o|T00eiT^ZYrg>c5WtI3l{rW`5JHc_ zXzqi}8RZH$?nvW#vzKMha_0&m)}E>aCGOaZGnGY`+_fuCh|<^d$tn#J1!xx`8!wD}Q7<_!7WAeN`VTuN%077i&y>>2L~Vh6VL z@nk0;OIlcD9KvgIn&X^!1akWFf_O7$71SRLBR$HW4Zm-H_wxY4$uRVH#DVD88~=68 zmon{k;+F$?RN<6x%-BY-_nYP5+USC)_&c49pm288t1WCL&}zS)Q>%S?T>tjJrS(5-wDF)y&oBU z@Vx*n*qHB0xgEg7-@F~>E8v}-qQJg5xEofVL9~4kbbr+S9k1IQLwmJ)2ie|3vaeI` zUv2v?cKB%ffdzkD0-ngRfG*!TikrWO?Dw@e&O(;px^oZTgtrtn<8CgMW_=LaVUX$8 zq_sTZaI=ID4nj_YwK4{SPc)^=aDfhkjY`vPq&i$uo$#n@bYPuxjdev(8&~3N-}aGH z7qeUi&B1!eQzO^G9|m-*BvcR0$s3BL-D!+Ter=R#gY$^BAZeBcX%{%8yoiT+gEM8Dq*n*8Oqrnp~TI$@3Xqo)F|R zf#`|Iaz-awPPY&KZD!^Ru*gk+n!aKRR^dQ4Tqu)-k)$!!JRVY(0}9c)YSfb$vsi(h zQ<;gSuI!p63;RfJJpIp-8K_;pVsZg*1JV(=DweNt zi>51#ALUYgUXrsXES~jf1xKWX>~fa=Ns_KJtlVfGR?bP8^{zAOI4IfSsTDL-r(6!F z>Dp|4lD((%Ey2lNIdJskUO!yEKGQZ5$(?^E@kz2;CNG&{m|yA&W$%d1$>k^?{?W1* z{_P8WTfJPbPga2j>hD8LXn#EzfD2d!xm2Q6=p*eQ(Ojd9n5{FqfjNslbOOR1c9P!2 zK{;3=c@2tJ#$)Rw5mSrI58D(TgR%g9=wbv{s#3prsuaZv9}H@=b2OQ%N$>(#n$vR z*j)=4-Vzo4%5?k2ChTw8d-zD*J*u|5bH9-Dxl>7zZE$^I-|&|l3y@svOMWg`c;AQtMsU@D44(v-@?X7p2fhqr<3J0Sfg56r zcp&~3(~WZB1_K!mi#e1Q3wrM6ViSVNv+jeBs3FibNpx|al))ieFGC3wZbQ8rqtR<9K@`Kka50(eK!Fw0k-OjK8vpuyr22(k%`W${qft%I{Qb@HiW}4SpvzOufR6L)9XX$u z*nyn0;C0WKi(loqyy;av2o*do7inK2Y~0?ax;HMqjuSOmU!eEC=WlyrUb`DOI!9`Z z=E#KYPYqRUL`{K8ZeaJgd=6@EEKVAe6_!F}%Ggx=o6;PFY>!Q=Mvm%F1!$nPb# z{SCc?(U*xId51?aGe0hlF*zz7I%*3Vj6ELP2(Mf{9(xV+5c+-q0=}AU{SYn4cc|&$ zSQj94=y~MWuQ)opy}*B&sqpzdq~`bIP^0pqYdS#h$)m6VdR7D85*AiA-V|8lBB+R0 z$Y7wb!3imCenVBL6I0rgzHC-Qr&G%MBxk!f$TH@InRYWM- zX9`A=zrl76qusOGe@l#&_6 zjI|?7vdfx`fjaw6O+mSC)GbZ?ONN3MbtCh#;g=<=sxqByYkJX zjxw|G8x{q0>q|9T0+}Co_l_gcTqbh(%RiJ3$J9J4>ZWg>GzX5VCJ;$@<){kl^=FS_ zvV~246wxgbR!ge%MUH9iA6Frupbafz$aJZxI-AyZEux!uE!k(|O=yu7PCv`*L01+@ zsv1aGdsDM7sg-)uYqO=cabrz5NE@{MY{EOHv4j_Ew|DC#kD%PlG1fB?YltW|u+w9N z!cjxa+1N8O@oQ=VS?iHr(;T<0b$`%As%yv^>9Stf#85x0Zs1e5#I5OUn$JmgwXW)@ zC)kY1cJkBvLQ7CZ$G@Uh>7z7UPvfd#Jzmm+u~nzP^;%rIrRmmC^}T}Fr+RxO{mQ5M z7soQNtu^>*1iJ=>UEDy^>5gVrW0k&UfF#Z#wG(HmkZ*PBs=7+fb087@`udJ%9)HdUdrMLK8zG#ChP97*h zFPV?28VN`?zx7An1GnXe)7S=h{)MI9u3SMUjEbi|=8sWA^4m$-yTZ4;cl2y`1|;3X z=+!>5jTV7dx98!4UY%Z@L&lHmiW7_Nx7Uci9l15aZ+$^hTk+t}g#nDYh~m7z&j_#5$gg3eO8a?~x#1DyVTY2FKte$_YM9S{+7c}dJgB68B z9VW|)T|wB#%kx6U`+^Yo7$>iR2k}&(Alazphmw)(B^kvsa*6> zd0{S}VV-HLYr;Eo{qzXKI^_V{=$4JKrVE?DQ{%4WqbWEQrj(=32 zai5=m<%s#;IRY@KdO4Z_7!-{x%m8EnroVEgXyk16**()gu?%u%rdCG64xRv=PZcA8 znTZ|1#K{WyL@A#GiF{7w)7=H|r{Mp0bzj2S!OihMruX+4e`)`jvC8Mj&PMhwj(^57 z@%l$C1#oqCGy6vp`ScPsbGI@vQ75u$BfeFCM!OZ#JcOhsP*s82x3miQwd)jBx*!0 z@U|PblE5-@gsp;rF`bXxT`NFf{QVZOQMv4dM8zWJXqx#D-?Wy^_u$(?nZioIZ&KHc z>$l0dabKsmIF=)9*h2s!p4e!Y>Mc#;5x|2mkDFzoJ>mn7`4^9TF73e@?m5o{B$@ocq?mX}lVxoaD%(-d4Rsi%edt<*@Uj|DVgTDbIPOMnSoEGAX zt-2BVA;a56o0dV8lY3CWPM!t<*mhqf;}+)8+%m0?Gjoj zc@_$Jk;n4vPwt+9_~}OGIkhiddx}^ns)Qs&TaIrVhA6ePGzu8?Z?ieSOVQ;BlX6+5}kF88*n#g(!j-KEG(hXF% zl=xBjiWSb0GKz6C(kcCI^AlWPpIy}apq?+>-cAYQ+4%Pwei7af?q)UcU+sLEZfNM& zFjTNR_z?KmC@9!Dv3To^z`o79``UF^5sjSP&9%$Z?mFZ#;Zj8|Qw}|jfTg7pIY(1# zXRG@BNXUAy9Jy($O{T$ z<3&f&!v~4UeoM}$GbSCd94W2v9Z$eibjh;R7AkA9$Yv}Sic8XRmNo36`Bv-;ww{{Q z82|hu@~!qXQe$~8W;2zA<}q@q4Kb^rWq-70xs^C+LQXlg)^sN8ROp>0$gQV|m*(Mu zOZZ)t)rrQ!^-$`jv}8m1AiYwnU&KN%tEtnswm^TO35?PT4wy3fiQ-uBbAAIj`FLz~ z`eZ^5_@&rvVT22g!k9#xrF+!*ig5_O-oTWfq7#Tpay5~i+0!yV9i?tSFcN#WLTzWk zves)c>pj9 zQqvrWVx(rVfXHyrN-LH2WLAVKbY)@fktv0G&xOA*^P~97#Qh&cyP|Th$pUV%~!uhf5!Y86A!h5_k|rsb*?ja zu^x(KY0JyLD00s;_o=#=w=iDgiESWK(X`w0;@zWh62XFFqO8)B7ghpK>kV?ga&7iCd)#l%e#>M&gwdAXXOD8fNUh2@2T#u6V z?*gex#l%c3ziX<7N{C{l5zKhA$c3>6X4i7tx?xFZ_Pz0HtA5|~5t*wirsnhRg=#B4 zBI(CKZ{8R^Fv6JV=8iS3)-=L;FLF{J@TH+G?jl==p$;Pb-Pq#m@jV)Qyd={E%-_Yn z>eZL-z+Zw60i>rl-x_ZbO}MqCJ{ed-pf-NCIJHNW&-Xxf3RV#h{lZr5&(QX= z=%M6qTrL(m3K+X_cwb)UCD=qEppzT8qmAo^%L9iS45$)@&$h z3a9c3{U>dgz@um2)6SGs9ecb2ozfo!vZE`ZrUKU@*_+|!se9>Sfy0cK^V+2Z%a*W{ zO8q_SAkpak{6O+M$aXFA}M zgzL_Qp7gopv$4cM&R`9SdcSoeas(DwjxO!*3JKevi>T9kKbZL4&OzPMwd+6xP_HJMf zxK*u0;f9ZsM}tgu^7)IZ*<&FD9l353)|d*Go= z>^;RE{1(?AcT!Uu%|~nEar=d7F@bC70gc5SQAz`}CDte65XN%_0{o-u`*1su!%5Fz zhJNB!hU2XThM$b3JUZt4l(|OjbO0S#22R%E6`b}0MOhH5z4vHSM^nc1!>sZH@w*_d&@Kn zh@Ighc5M@AljO$IEt!{`m>DZY;*+%T3Ez6n;bR{*z3(6<=Sj&DKA_om89EAPfH$Zf zjnmtl=(u9K7f(f9{;_CDmU`=HU;x)tdHMwIa_(~YzZ3dbmj0blwtpw|e`EPS+(6XK z#l+dl(bd8E4{ZL6F320%eFA+IF*!{!Wg0mnS4%THBUdXEqklVy8`)XedI2c^!$$SD z(bmY~6KXU6+f(>&EG0$$x}DOZ>c7 z%$Nax0RMjyfIl4QpZn`?+VRKt@9x};UH>9Gs-G0&kL@q5u#t<|Uu^3CH8obwF0LY$ zM$Z3aK-TDAGAr9(J^c541DO6?k-vG6nEmI*W-EIO0E32=y^y_&)jx{A;xw#GT`gVy z#i{;07yrCjm>ECE`bT1C{TI{vWK0ff_EvxPN(26Sj{bAqO#j7u{~b4Q~6%u4{9gYXkk?pJNkJ0N0KM*Q;$u4?+1YW^Zd7tIN z6h1n=JUsS3{xEnv&+S>(x5?{S(f6tAS*ZsC2BND4$NAcVaYy&u_&ehTxLF#w(#D)l z=hV+p-;Yi3;RlfHWvG<>a1Ae76tvLB;!t4)y>M7T4rnbsucv`uO z7v@G^ubUxW9(q9GA+GI8%ZOGf20r}GKIy)7=7 zx>4P#3E6dQm%iCnwX4!(p13WX;n_G7P|?_F6Ln*w67GoFfkSEc#Iwz#i_Y3mLzxW1 z5F?{7EoE90CvA-H5gcpj4yQ!l6bd9PID)&8vXfJ6NF#4&PEg}s)R1u?Pt}Lz@RTHt zWjb&OJiW{)q)g_*&IDMK(2So`1ibH@SCb89_{3j%(%!qDwkO;BodyJ1=giEp z1G_^U^b4;weeW8O2Cqv~mlj}7`5;Yr@5tJu@IRw4PTpiqWn0K5tubq<1S?_u z6Aj|io)~#2UVwuh46<`wVc*2P!_xSHZG|xe(ucsbYnM{|%GUc*York`Y1d3j<)5I@ zJ)ZRq{Z@L;q#{Dj!f81CEMkcb8HFOl_O}oWTsSFJOOLjH2kxDg=r_+4z z>a7e43VwqHgU5wM3W;UgY=0eYK^&Q{JL{ zT%|+%Ax{42U#P*1uj;);eTG^C&mim9+0$l=C>PQpN5B=6$AEZa#0yXj%G84ZRJ5&e10+r*HwHQk@|1tLTxy-J2ljeX^_U5v63Y5DR{cPgR+H-` zL;qSvH@ti(yPf9^B3C&Q6ex~g>QTbRF`j~Olw8eA90vUZ?6Q$Vpl=-i=GjfZT>os@ zj^(G+7gtgNfrO&0#-)^>dS^uX3RMv|n`cbutDTOL-OEzBNwvYRlsHkPkC);lkCbz>?t81(djzZ!ZssY9ami5#^C7?HT;?#Wbr+MWC#spa2$*qRaRTxO6^SdU zHz;&hV9BV$KcJ_OS?3rME1>^nMoatovDyw z1h9I14q$?fG;@l??k6DSf>S52BZE?hSI^ixb>C!^OhBbT?7V%tEd=3&qk;7n5###V zKuyT?Ol>sX=g#Ps?rOmFl0+Aye!hxPcuApEb$dl9=O>suIxg~a;e$1m`=Q%FKxSl- z@)o{KVV=dYS8Hd)?iJB_hS$H>zv$=4`9>%DYu&TjAzQlIvfA1ayhWTbg+Rm=8=-l; z_LfmE8b8ZT+tyS7JRxxDb!5K{(Tz>!&Bu_O7lDa^I<@YV(WiB7GMN&N(Z}qlNFqAZlHfGD+s!ntq1vp9)k`nmq z+yWmTpZuugjAX)_3>%n@wY4~+B^d-qdzvU*jjY6K9GN?M6z4@b3uCads2(;CQy%s( zdo~=~L<~=Q^IVE;++HjfJMd6T@mImMUNjVm*V0flRmC{FOXdKoq$q(&oJl+K1a`@} z_5zKxbd8pM6F5#qD{g*wLzHhI!lfZeP3%Qg~+q_DYFhu3V;3^SO+J7b}@4nX#FS z&fW++hK;S}xpvaBHB?r2NvUXjI0#h-+523@4hJ&zDQrwIiwmiWw>w5AE}Mu8d07W> zzWIx3)T#VH21|F`8o}>F6R9>;AR!tCV&WkW!M9aB?&$_j?YxXR0CtE+X597Bt0}y& zUf!+`n~(}!-0|peTn)kihI_gses52ajkW>L50-|ChrZ^c;gZsP6AL!)TjifQJOt8w zDc&6SM~gvHNi`u0IQGv+BBTYPTb%Jsc`;r;_bn-4R1^rSk_w9BTE~TWuwv$nou%j< zLgN{Y3o#y(MGj+x1%%H6NI0NT$_6yHh4QuHrzV7^F%O-|} zfzh^G4K}dGbB$Nu@v9BubZ*5Nxg_IN6l3>EcAfARdVuD=V8gN8+6E|UGbWMS?&HvOwKkXi93$*A}{3euskIATG!nN=D)(vIEmh*X$_{*`;W z&V4ozJx0B{#WSpTW*%&sqFAx>?72Zvj~quK?rcEX=kKyMKfBxVfTb&bg5ajP(Qu~xvek)TXJ+k)Fp3cRiK1woFrvzAIi&Ixk6lW!)2+@0} zk&g4OLDfsomBJr{>FTBp{S;m2@1R*(3j2kc5~oJ5Vs)?~iIZ2>)l9=6rT$KmDJ_>; z^8B-I5kbgvO%PCO;l>lyWQAI!&N>3boRFxj$v`w&%9zsh! zo=$=f3f9q$@jLYd4U-fWJdbS7%_5j8F;}}x7U)sMc-Kw3&g0Z3Gr#x8CDmL_z@zFU zvdHWZCPqfw)9;aZwX(7|p90(XkNe@XE#^a>%suTJ@HH+*x5pL)2=X=hD+`Dv6uZAJW~cg+7t~cFKfbl{yc8%_N3Y2*W0(lGLi}jFO0Iil$5QO-;sP^C zzjHZMhz__-bf%|SML+6w@-W!m~8VzK#$THS*H8$b21eO z6(3?o7q*k9?piWy)(eH*Rl;~J=vzT{2itSFr z5K|?`LZ#W=fCsJtXW22*X9vl}hY>gjmaSz?(HLj@Vr205bGK0=mQE@nQc5vh{)A-; z$r-!wi$s(bO<~-5ktMfbsUi#nH*_D6ZaeKVA?az%0(j&dO;k8`wv=r&g-keh!E-+N zerQ+wXpxQj>FEoh=xniqbHw=|96F*&g{Wy{-HIjq`+co3tr)sAp z4zoI^J%cZ?3=Dbd{xiXPrqm~5@6}5F7&kQxHy`^EJ6MEC_@)$IP?Pm@H`M7XV>SV| zGW|;`m$a$XO;Tl5W_d^n|!1XFN?+)=Jdg0|tHV*=Gw|#_$86aUy zI|D27+X;^{k^%8ojJ*aGvyW){r^9#MtmZY18eUbZe(+$w2)bYh`qlKo1HR$b!wX+? zRSiApd*Z%>rR?Bv!lCY3-JoIxjw`~$O41#q1Psp7xKml8?^z%ywkpo}gQ2%#+#XMj-TOHVNpVk8+` zTX~Z#?s_8jyIe~or__hoQbyoJ4&5_iV)V;3B6u+jI(a5^I;+2Ib*S+AwqymP`R2%4 zGSCCcB}oe=JRUATNXmCYQ92tVn9~3j>n`+5G2C~E{9$LPcWgQaB!MNtx-$6%b8Yi_ z(~Po}QjZD)>AoM zC%`S1Tb{=X5x;oy82ireZs^V-^Wxmro$1BJUGWyagNluYji-&ajrm@AXMhg9=!_mHfS9a~t4=0KzGB2>BCd^6T8(y!FuX0;M z&cV5ZH~7QKcxDx^s)@-}>a-drCne@eE>&KOAg2Vh3X0uTJ*vqNUGersFO8(fA$LyC ze9sDZeN6J^R4%x;0$C>CA-_W(GJMzis*};2cg`B8r&6a??j_q2(H-QI{sI&}JMsZ~ zbT?#yQCoOf(i^d~sK7YwxLxiq6E~WsDfW;!I;)&evYl@71Qioo1{Z@diElY1ObfsS z1AThuEzp>_@6?lz(3AS!LTjEf2RLQg-sgfRNJ0xLHV=?#;6Of?V-))M{cBiyV>=?W zmk`MtRiCu&Rg--8LT&h~Kzgc@^K@TIDogT>n3VC&vY?z(Qpehr+*j;JpOk}anr@^% zip#49@^H1Ua>E_fospe05rm#O7cTo-U?=zN6x!)i_?DM(CLWNctl90IPMO_9@5;!RE-a98sK&Sj#P%kvx*+%vF4LqEbf?20-W@H2Vn2cg${p)>? z#OA8>INhD*c*O!bWdt?^Ug}HXSbWfHuh#3qeyrpbdZ#gcPYRtPR9Llt8}zU80=DUW zf&31JZh3M>XeqR?$;Q8MuBPqhVN!EX&EPImcXcV9c>e>NO!Ws#%kd)zP3qRuR_Kny z-3)%_b_{z&m7a+F+S>V5j0Z(wkIfhn&!V`~9PrDj6F=)j&|df+1bF=Inuf)WhKKp_ zhpS@61pYgi(b-~*JJE#XJ9MS_Add|Gw}h^Ewd(gKMn)Uj=-mZ5$MjniVU?@E6PQ=( z0SH2(3%!ugR}qio(iIA# zORm5QIKLlorV(f!nV6#uO~~}Z!bONpgTxN7)<24Cb3FQa7>ynRJBE2MF>|3Sk+9!D ze<Cp}IGsOG>3YwL^ zox#b;xPzm(2Uw6t`TYpym6{0F2I`tds z%W^K!p{(-%Q^~c!Lz%Vl+ET5GTBFEq_$cH0zH=WGV&op<(#j=7VqM3`H7(VYVT33| z)Jjo_TDit&ql8+DVw5E8mJOv)F1zQQF|PI7@0)kdJm);;@;vW3&zbrC=Kp`s^%-Gi9^%+Hh3FIvv%jtk*xe>{u=F z3AN_r*(YNealo`i0mZJ(^Z{ zCo-R9^bdC5nKYgDolb5}ZTViMP)xK!m~d%0-Z?rTwLYs=^0&@qx_&I@CIh!$hHY2F zhZ4S&-0giOBu6^gD;epK|J13Nm`6wmylF1$(^qf1{_|NT1~t0kC9UE58}xbel_jxw z`3>RX>fZRj47^FMC@oXWjp*w&W!EmC>hErS$GwmeHlu5wcHbM&u?;9uXz%CYMouT6FSwZ=5T zu%nrYd2G`AePugXYtA1;VUaIBv)uK(mC4aYPr^9h&!#u&Wr)eoi8ZGc~SueD# z$2LUQ=>=_TmL%!KG-PO_G^1LJ^rUb(tD146;#uLNX^gr#|wH10$btTmAvM&(tVs*RUtqX!~~g z!;(~VXO8eMxE$?Pvt*(D!Y4G$4b^w~C7)NOX@_8^qaSNduDW$k>ZW;^R=H!CO1a$^ zo6LqTQLBlH8+rm`%*4`toVXXy9g^gqFmn`O_m!E96{FmuJd!=q#Dq-@I3RpYT z9l;}{W)I@JLF-?m?$> z)|j8_P!~OvY!phCPmI0vXrOGM)VzRowcEH1y}6rC5%%a)t&AZJhdDKlR5Cq6KH7Js zn;wzdmE2wIWh&SV89%&I8bk9^66r*}!Z1|(P=*QN^fPUp1FAv&Z_kXo=XbSe(97`Z>`n&!CEl^qwsQj5m94W;Lj1%s)O+|=zU7r5}i9f*o;`G48{frciM}b=2Rs0 zHui@axi#I*uyl!xS=q$4$R@yM?^XkXg3QlC0?yjj3dd3+o86UdiXMs=DUL?F1_&s+ zZbRp@sCgp!?dMqS-MRjO5s;)Uwf%?o9G17M32Gxg#9)LriQgf{&Zlu!Vr)LCwQX&U z*Yes`B*tp3LnYS0FiI?rZQ0Rc^4G<6;a<$`HtxHtYtmoMmIr$;l zebwogHVdR(_FFIB4HOhkXzb2N_wD+-J5FsU zhPfQSMQKcK>T1SDmUq{w^g*BJqiz#c5x&wF9{s_xr^ViDGdZqXuFR@ZS^Xzle5JEuB^TrXO zC!^Qy-q)O{+qP#qa=Fga6rZoG3LgpvtAc}Yvx|aIVwWPs-vrF}+UZ&vSt(n4`nU(G z()@f}d}l#lK48wR`xmGj3*peJcq|zWlOPCS!~i+x(PzJjl#>WN;Cl`!pHa*q<;XBx zZ~hmgoQn|8hm5~I5xnvK1uFm6qHXNQlX~i-bksdLj`C79v2^2?QiJcag~mlZAirYk9r++NBbYN8tFy7vdFi z;cz(K;x9n-d55FTk+cz3%)&TDNZNtiX*BV4Lx=-hrok)?I|$)y&*MVF^U2T_bU(MC z{ou$o#r-axbU!q#1{2jFwBkVq!#_|%9gyIG)`RZif6#M(pqd}u1H%hwJ#Zi!V3DA; z45$VM5JUjcO9Yar2NDs2NLV0Ykn|x4WFb6|NSTBOk_-~KXQXacM*(>puZ*hmSaAPHA0&_X&6VI@uoUi71nS&r^Yru8N1i-T#6nms zL<9{fcoG4-mp8L!es15WofiXq8Wr*j!lSe3xd3X7p9eP#xB)T4)1T`ULU%tP2zCP` z2ppSvp@{?nj(|RZ=ILMxi2~vad7*u0bPySaKj z_S%AWFa<|iVuOssF17(fB;sNlKt~1L7jhQKCRtivwp3ls56bYvoV@f^Tp611cp z1tKrK4`6t)T?!fb?pWXp_|}K!^<~gq0BMQNJrdE%Gt3=XBZP%R^Ya5+ckV$2Bi{pH aht5))0vRrJ26t7#ctl80L4ms4K=2;}4>Sz` literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/Manuscript/fig2.pdf b/Manuscript/fig2b.pdf similarity index 100% rename from Manuscript/fig2.pdf rename to Manuscript/fig2b.pdf diff --git a/Response_Letter/Response_Letter.tex b/Response_Letter/Response_Letter.tex index 128db85..73ec0a3 100644 --- a/Response_Letter/Response_Letter.tex +++ b/Response_Letter/Response_Letter.tex @@ -35,14 +35,19 @@ A few things need to be modified -- minor -- for the paper to be accepted. } \\ \alert{ +We thank the reviewer for these positive comments and supporting publication of the present manuscript. } \begin{enumerate} \item -{Table I should be moved to the SI. Key entries could be kept if explicitly discussed in the manuscript.} +{Table I should be moved to the SI. +Key entries could be kept if explicitly discussed in the manuscript.} \\ \alert{ +We would prefer to keep Table I in the main text as it is the core table of the present manuscript. +We believe that it would be unfortunate to move (parts of) the table in the SI as it would not be ideal for the reader to have to switch between the main article and the SI depending on the system he/she is interested in. +We hope that the reviewer will understand our motivations. } \item @@ -50,18 +55,21 @@ A few things need to be modified -- minor -- for the paper to be accepted. The very important classes of transition metal complexes are not covered.} \\ \alert{ +We have modified the conclusion to stress these two points. } \item {Make it VERY clear that the excitation energies are Single-State CASPTX excitation energies.} \\ \alert{ +The reviewer is right. We have added this additional information in the "Computational Details" section of the manuscript. } \item {The authors should point out the difference between dynamic sigma polarization and so-called left-right polarization (https://doi.org/10.1021/jp9528020).} \\ \alert{ +This has been clarified in the discussion section of our revised manuscript. } \end{enumerate} @@ -75,6 +83,8 @@ I have however some comments that I would like the authors consider. } \\ \alert{ +Thank you for recommending publication of the present manuscript. +Our response to Reviewer \#2's comments are given below. } \begin{enumerate} @@ -84,6 +94,7 @@ I have however some comments that I would like the authors consider. CASSCF has largest errors, sure, but it would be interesting to see how broad is the distribution in comparison to caspt3, represented in the same way.} \\ \alert{ +The histogram for CASSCF has been added (and discussed) in the revised version of the manuscript. } \item @@ -103,12 +114,18 @@ I would say the latter, so while the TBEs are useful, a comparison with the expe } \item -{Can the authors also discuss if there is any basis set effect? Are the TBEs obtained with the same basis set as their calculations? +{Can the authors also discuss if there is any basis set effect? +Are the TBEs obtained with the same basis set as their calculations? Probably not. The authors could be more a bit more specific about the method/basis set of each of the TBEs in the SI, so that everyone can compare for a specific molecule (if desired) the setups in which the values where obtained. Again, this should be discussed against the experimental value in order to convey a clear recommendation to the readers.} \\ \alert{ +All calculations reported in the present manuscript have been performed with the very same basis as the TBEs (aug-cc-pVTZ), as mentioned in the "Computational Details" section. +We have modified the corresponding sentence to stress this further. +Having an augmented triple-$\zeta$ basis allows us to describe faithfully all excited states (including the Rydberg states). +Therefore, there is no basis set effect between the CASPT2/CASPT3 and TBE excitation energies. +Moreover, because the basis set effects are extremely transferable within wave function methods, we can safely assume that the present conclusions would be identical in a small or larger basis set. } \end{enumerate}